Rick Grimes:
A pair of cowboy boots.
"They'll help you ride your horse better."
Carl Grimes:
A ring pop.
"Since I can't get you a real ring, here's a ring pop."
Daryl Dixon:
A book
"Ya told you that ya missed the library the most, so I got ya this book. I thought ya could read it to me when the others go to sleep."
Glenn Rhee:
A Walkman + three cassettes to go with it
"I know you hate quiet when you sleep, so I figured you could use it."
Negan:
A teddy bear.
"Now you have something to cuddle when I'm not here."