🌺 Seokjin

235 14 15
                                    

1st Place
Picture Perfect by xomiin

Judged by _itsmingenius_
49/50 points, 98%

Cover and First Impressions: 5/5
Attention Grabbing: 5/5
Unique Storyline: 9/10
Good Grammar: 10/10
Story Arch: 10/10
Believable Characters: 10/10

"The cover is beautiful. The authors writing is wonderful. I kept reading until I fell asleep. I had to read 2 chapters over because I don't remember them. A cliché of sorts, but one that's not seen as often. The author knows how to build their story and kept it interesting."

"

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.


2nd Place
Stranger by uhjoonies

Judged by _itsmingenius_
44/50 points, 88%

Cover and First Impressions: 4/5
Attention Grabbing: 5/5
Unique Storyline: 9/10
Good Grammar: 10/10
Story Arch: 8/10
Believable Characters: 8/10

"I honestly thought it was a romance texting story. I was wrong. I love the photo of Jin the author used. I wanted to see where the author was going to go with it. I can honestly say that I've come across a handful or 2 of this kind of storyline. They're usually about any one of the maknae line or Yoongi though, not Jin. It was refreshing. Jin truly has the mind of a serial killer in this one. I don't remember too many, if any at all, grammatical errors. That is the first and last thing I notice and it sticks with me. I felt a little build up and then it hit me like the pavement after falling off a building. It was abrupt but it definitely was NOT uninteresting. This is my favourite that I've been assigned to read so far."

<no picture available>


3rd Place
Giving up on you by Jamsnbun  

Judged by NayanaVadakkekara
43/50 points, 86%

Cover and First Impressions: 5/5
Attention Grabbing: 3/5
Unique Storyline: 8/10
Good Grammar: 9/10
Story Arch: 8/10
Believable Characters: 10/10

"Cover is perfect. Plot is good. The description is classy and detailed, but is a bit close to too much making the story slow, for the starting chapters at least. And due to that, I think the story grabs attention of the readers(because of the skilful writing and description), but does not entices much(because the pace feels slow). Grammar is perfect; good use of vocabulary. Spelling mistakes spotted; even the names of the characters have spelling mistake( 3 different versions of the name 'Maram' was identified). Characters are realistic and relatable. Progression is smooth. A very well written story."

"

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
The Magic Shop Awards 2019 CLOSEDWhere stories live. Discover now