AU Sanses Boyfriend Scenarios (M4F)

He Scares You

Classic:

You were walking to the house, but got lost. It began to get dark, and you were walking in basically every direction. You realised you were lost, and curled up in an alleyway.

You stayed there for a while, focusing on your breathing to hopefully calm down. It worked for a bit, until you heard a rustle of boxes behind you.

That sent you off running. You had heard of bad people living in this part of town. Or at least you think it was this part.

A figure in the dark caused you to freeze in place, shivering in fear. You then recognised the figure as they stepped into the streetlight.

"Easy, (Y/n)... It's just me..." Sans uttered.

You rushed into his arms, gripping onto him and hitting his shoulder gently. "Y-you numbskull! You sc-scared me!"

Sans hugged you, chuckling a bit, "Oh... I'm sorry... I didn't mean to scare you so badly..."

You were crying in fear. Sans stroked your hair, teleporting home in the process. You had moved in a few weeks ago after the parent issue.

"Sweetheart, I'm sorry... please forgive me for scaring you like that..." Sans kissed your head gently.

When you finally settled enough, you managed, "I... I forgive you... But I'll get you back!"

Sans laughed slightly, "Good luck with that, doll face... It takes a lot to scare me..."

Underswap:

He's a cinnamon roll. You barely got scared by him. The only time you did... well...

You were just asleep on the couch. You'd had a nightmare and went to the couch to stay awake.

Papyrus had left for work earlier than normal, but he acknowledged you. He told you to get some rest for your sake, and you ended up falling asleep.

You were startled awake when Sans slammed the door open, and then shut. You jolted, screeching slightly. You glanced around in a panic.

Sans saw you, and tried to touch your shoulder to help you. You flinched away, and your skele boyfriend retracted a bit.

"Shhhhhh.... It's okay...." Sans uttered, moving slowly towards you.

You were feeling cornered. You scurried off the couch and into the kitchen, hiding under the sink in a curled up ball.

You silently cried to yourself, not knowing what you were so scared of. In your mind, everything was a blur. You were so disoriented.

You heard footsteps, and then a small thud, like someone sat down in front of your hiding spot. You were more awake now.

"(Y/n)... It's okay... Everything's okay... I promise... I was just upset when I came in because Papyrus had gone to Muffets and almost ended up drunk... again... I would never hurt you..." Sans whispered.

You hesitated, before opening the door gently. You peeked out slowly, and Sans was smiling softly at you.

"See? Everything's okay... I wouldn't let anything happen to you... Okay? Nothing will hurt you with me here..."

You were about to hug him, but hesitated. Sans saw what you wanted, and opened his arms for you, letting you decide whether to hug him or not.

You did, and clung to him. You held back your tears as much as possible, though. Sans calmed you down, and you silently vowed to get revenge, even if it were a small jumpscare.

Underfell:

Oh boy. Scaring you was a favourite past time for sans. He would jump out of a closet when you least expected it, use magic to levitate objects and freak the hell out of you, and make his eyes glow brighter in a dark hallway, so all you could see were his glowing eyes.

You hated it. One time though, he took it too far. He had told you to head to Grillbys because he had a surprise for you that he had to set up. When you got home, you opened the door to see the kitchen in disarray.

Pans and pots knocked over, bones from the cabinet spilled out, and... the thing that struck you...

A knife, caked in dust and blood, sticking out of a scarf that was familiar to you.

You shuddered, hoping the evidence was wrong. You walked into Papyrus' room, seeing nothing, and then went to Sans' room. You checked inside, seeing 2 glowing red eyes.

But you saw a glint of silver, and you were sprinting into Papyrus' room. You hid in his closet. You trembled, shivering. Where was Sans? Was Papyrus dead or alive? Were you going to die here?!

You sobbed quietly, letting yourself go for once. You were worried for Sans, not knowing whether he was alive or not scared you more than the red eyes and knife caked in blood and dust.

You tried to collect your thoughts, to rationalise the situation, but your mind was overflowing with fear. You heard the door open slowly, and quiet footsteps coming to your hiding spot.

The light flicked on, and you sas a shadow just under the door. The door opened quickly and you curled up, trembling and crying.

You heard the sound of metal hitting the ground, and felt arms wrap around you. In a fit of panic, you struggled, trying to get out of the grip.

"Shhhhhh.... Sweetheart, it's me.... It's me..." Sans whispered.

You froze. Another trick of his? You growled through your tears, "You... need to st-stop pranking me...."

"I know... this went too far... I'll admit that... I got Papyrus to help with this one... He agreed to do it because you had apparently stolen his spaghetti."

"I told him I never even touched it!"

"It was me... I took the spaghetti..."

"Why?"

"Well... You wouldn't understand..."

"I will get revenge on you..."

"Good luck with that, sweetheart..."

Birdtale:

He didn't like scaring you much. He laughed at it for a moment, but then would try and calm you down. He hated seeing you upset.

He had never truly scared you. You never had a reason to say you'd get revenge, but... You wanted to see if you could scare him...