Orange you glad I'm back?

Part Seven

"What.. did you just say..?" I asked, looking at Awsten who was completely in shock. "No, no. I killed you!" He yelled, slapping himself. "Awsten." I whispered, grabbing both of his hands so he wouldn't do anything else.

"You're dead!" He yelled again. "What the hell?" Otto asked, running up to us. He then saw the boy. "Okay, while you two are having your weird moment. I'm gonna untie this dude." He said, crouching to the ground. "Holy hell! Your foot is gone!" Otto yelled. "Please, just untie me!" The boy yelled. Otto then started untying him. I turned my attention back to Awsten.

"Awsten, what are you talking about?" I asked, still holding his hands. He finally looked at me. "He was one of my victims." He whispered. I tried to remain as calm as possible but how do you stay calm in a situation like this?

"Hey, let's go outside." I said, leading him out of the barn doors so he can calm down. As we saw that we were alone he melted into my arms and started sobbing. How did Ray and Frank get one of his victims? Was it a coincidence or did they know it would effect him this much?

"I can't do this." He whispered in a shaky voice. I pulled away from the hug but he still had his arms around my waist. I rested my hand on the right side of his face. He looked at me with pain and tears in his eyes. Gosh, he really did change. If he didn't then he wouldn't be crying over that kid.

"Awsten." I whispered. He let out a small chuckle and shook his head side to side. "Who is that boy?" I asked in the softest voice possible. He sighed then took a deep breath. "He was a fan. I saw him walking out of a store with the "fandom" vinyl. I surprised him and he was so happy to meet me. Then, I drove home with him in his car. When he drove us to his house, I got out of the car and pretended to leave, but I didn't. I broke into his house and drove him insane. I drove him to hate me. Then, he brought up you. I got angry and well, I, chopped his foot off." My mouth dropped opened.

I was in shock, what do I even say to that? "I regret it, (Y/N). I really do regret it. I shouldn't have ever hurt him, I shouldn't have ever hurt anyone. I'm sorry." His voice was shaky and full of pain. I felt pity for him. He wouldn't have tried to kill that kid if he didn't being up me. Is all his killings my fault? No, I can't think about that right now.

"Look, this is your chance to do some good." I said with a smile, trying to bring some light into this situation. "What?" He asked with a confused expression. "Well, instead of taking that kids life, you can help save it."

He leaned in and left a peck on my lips. I felt my face get brighter and brighter the longer I looked at him. "What would I do without you, jelly bean?" He laughed, running his fingers through my hair.

A loud scream coming from the barn broke the moment. "Otto.." I whispered, running out of Awsten's arms. "(Y/N) stop!" He yelled, grabbing my hand. I looked at him with annoyance and confusion. "Let me go in first." He then let go of me and ran into the barn.

After he entered, I ran in. "Holy hell." Awsten whispered, standing a few feet in front of me.

I saw Frank, Ray, and Mikey all standing in the middle of the barn. Frank had Otto in a head lock and held a knife to his throat. "No.. this can't be right. Mikey.." I whispered, my voice getting shaky.

"Plot twist!!" Frank screamed, accidentally pushing the knife closer to Otto's throat, making him flinch. "How? You were sent to prison!" Awsten yelled, forming his hands into fists. "Exactly. I WAS in prison. Not anymore." Mikey said with a little smirk.

"Oh, where is my manners? Hi (Y/N)!" Mikey said, walking up to me. Awsten then stood in front of me. "Don't worry Knight. I'm not here to steal your girl." He smiled. Awsten didn't answer. "Ray is going to steal her for me." I then felt someone grab me from behind. I screamed and tried to reach for Awsten but I couldn't.

Who I assumed was Ray was holding me by my waist and my back was up against his chest, my feet off the ground. "Let go of her!" Awsten yelled, charging at Ray. "If you hurt him, Frank will slice Otto's throat." Mikey said, making Awsten stop right in his tracks. "I see I can still control you, lover boy." He laughed.

"Awsten." I whispered, feeling my eyes start to get watery. "Take her to the cabin and make sure she doesn't escape." Mikey commanded to Ray. "No! Let me go!" I yelled, while Ray threw me over his shoulder. "Awsten!" I yelled, reaching my hand out to him. "I'll save you! (Y/N), I'll save you!" He yelled back.

"Bye (Y/N)!" Frank said with a big smile. I threw him a bird right as Ray lead me out of the barn.

As we arrived at the cabin, the same one where they took me the first time. Ray put me on the couch and sat down in a chair, facing me. "Look we don't have much time. You need to save that boy." He said, with a rushed tone. "I'm sorry, what?" I asked with a little laugh. "Look, Frank forced me to help with his murders. He said if he didn't then he would kill Gerard. Gerard is my best friend and I couldn't do that. I hate helping him but it's keeping him alive." Ray said with a sigh.

"Wait, wait. So, you're a good guy?" I asked again with a chuckle. "No, I'm not. I've helped kill people. But I didn't want to, I don't want to hurt you. But Mikey and Frank are making me. I was going to tell you all this the first time I took you, but I didn't have the chance to." He said, rubbing his eyes with his hands.

"When we were in the car you could have." I pointed out. "Mikey was listening to everything. I couldn't."

After Ray told me everything he pretend to tie me to the chair he was sitting on just in case Mikey or Frank came in. I could easily get through the rope. "Just pretend you're scared of me. They can't know I told you." Ray smiled.

The front door then slammed open, making me and Ray flinch. "Honey, we're home!" Frank yelled in a high voice. God, he really is crazy. Mikey then walked in after Frank and crouched down in front of me. "Ray, Frank, will you give me and (Y/N) a moment alone?" He asked, looking up at them, then looked at me.

I looked at Ray with with a terrified expression. He mouthed, "I'm so sorry." And left the room with Frank. "What the hell do you want?" I asked, trying to put on a brave face. "Well, I want you of course." He said with a smile. "Why do you want me?" I asked, my brave face falling off.

He then put his index finger under my chin and made my look up at him. "Awsten is so stupid for you. He would do anything to keep you safe. So, if I have you, I can control him." He said, getting off the ground and booping my nose. "Where is he?" I asked, feeling the anger in my boil.

"Oh, lover boy? He and Otto are still in the barn." He then stopped talking like he was holding back. "And?"

"And they have just became my new victims."

A/N: I hope you enjoyed this part! Sorry that I keep changing my username I'm making sure no one I know finds this account cause I don't wanna delete it. Anyways I hope you are all staying safe!💕