Orange you glad I'm back?

Part eight

"I won't let you hurt them!" I yelled, trying not to break free from the chair. "Oh," He started to laugh. "I'm not going to hurt them. Or, well, physically at least. No, no, I'm going to torture Awsten mentally. I don't care much for Otto, he's just a side piece in all this. You see, I'm going to use you to destroy the love of your life." He confessed with a laugh.

"He was a serial killer. His mind is already destroyed." I replied, trying to calm myself down. "Not quite. The reason he killed was toa keep you safe. If I put you in danger then I can get to him." He gave me a smirk as he got off the ground.

He snapped his fingers like an idea came to him. "Or! I could make him jealous. Oh, yes. That will really set him off, I'll pretend that I'm in love with you." "No! I'd rather you try to kill me then pretend to love me!" I yelled, feeling the anger coming back. He chuckled.

"Well, I better get going. I'm expecting someone." He then walked out of the cabin and slammed the front door shut. What the hell is going on? He wants to use me to hurt Awsten and he's expecting someone? Who is he expecting?

Ray then opened the front door, but he only walked in. "Ray, please Mikey said he's going to use me-" "I know." He said, cutting me off. He then sighed. "(Y/N)."
"Yes?" I replied.

"The person he is expecting, is.." He then stopped, debating whether to tell me or not. "Ray, who is it?" I asked with a shaky voice. "It's Geoff."

"I'm sorry, what? Geoff is in a mental hospital." I replied. "Mikey got out of prison, he can break Geoff out." He said with a sigh. "Look, we need to help Awsten, Otto, and that kid. Mikey doesn't care for Otto, he's mainly after Awsten for revenge. Since he got in the way when they were all in the woods that night. He broke Geoff out to help him."

"Ray, what are we going to do? You can't help because you're pretending to be the bad guy. I don't want to be used to hurt Awsten and I can't even bare to see Geoff after everything that happened." I said, feeling myself starting to get choked up.

He then put his hand on the side of my face, wiping my tears away. He's such a sweet guy, even though he barely knows me. He's still trying to save me and the boys. "I won't let anything bad happen to you. I can't promise that with the others, but I will try my best! Also, when Geoff gets here Mikey is going to bring him in here. Then we all are going to go to the barn and Mikey will, well, he will start on his plan to hurt Awsten."

"Wait, but-" the sound of the front door opening made me stop talking. "Hey guys!" Frank said with a cheerful tone, sitting on the couch. "Hey Frank, you the only one here?" Ray asked.

"Not quite." Frank said with a chuckle and looking at me, he pointed to the door with a smile. I looked to where he was pointing, I wish I didn't. "Hey (Y/N)." Geoff said with a big smile. I didn't answer, I was trying so hard not to run up and beat the hell out of him.

"You missed me?" He asked with a laugh, walking over to me and crouching to my level. "Not even a little bit." I replied, spitting in his face. "We're gonna have to change that attitude." He smiled, wiping my spit off of him.

"I see you two have reunited." Mikey said, walking into the room. "Now, let's play."

Ray had untied me and Mikey held my arm tightly, making it impossible to run away. Ray, Mikey, me, Frank, and Geoff all started walking to the barn, as we all were close to the entrance Mikey told them, "Go ahead and go inside. Make sure Awsten and Otto see Geoff. I need a moment with (Y/N)." They all nodded in an agreement and went inside the barn.

"Let go of me." I said, trying to get free from his grip. "Listen to me, if you don't follow what I say, I will kill Awsten in one snap." My heart dropped. "No, you can't." I said with a shaky voice. "Yes, I can. Or, Frank can. He can kill people in two seconds. So if you don't play along with my plan then he goes bye bye." He laughed.

What the heck do I do? I don't want to help hurt Awsten, but if I don't then I'll be the reason he dies. "Fine, I'll play along." I sighed. "Good, now let's go. They're expecting us." Mikey said, letting go of my arm and holding onto my hand.
I flinched, but let him do it knowing it was the only way to keep Awsten safe.

As me and Mikey walked inside, I immediately looked at Geoff. He was smiling at both of the boys.

"What the hell are you doing here?!" Otto yelled, I could see how anxious he was. "I came for a visit. I wanted to see how you guys are doing and from the looks of it, not very well." Geoff replied with a big smile. I looked over at Awsten who was already looking at me. He had so much sadness in his eyes. He looked down at me and Mikey's hands then back up at me.

I saw a couple tears fall from his eyes. "I see you all have reunited." Mikey chuckled, walking in front of the guys so Awsten and Otto could see us clearly.
"(Y/N), why are you holding hands with that douchbag?" Otto asked, staring at our hands. I didn't say anything, what do I even say to that?

"That's none of your business." Mikey spoke up. "He's making her do it," I looked up at Awsten who had a small smile. "My (Y/N) would never do that." Despite everything happening, what Awsten said made me feel so happy.

"Well Knight, you don't know her the way I know her. Isn't that right love?" Mikey said, pulling my face so he could look at me. I wanted to punch him right in his face, but I couldn't risk putting the guys in danger. "Hey, where's the guy with the cut off foot?" Frank asked, looking around the barn. "You guys took too long." Otto smiled. I felt Mikey squeeze my hand out of anger.

"Frank! He couldn't have gone far. Go out and found him, and bring him back." Mikey commanded.

"Yes, boss." Frank smiled, running over to the small table and grabbing a knife before running out of the barn.

"Oh and Frank!" He called out. "Yes?" "I don't care if he's dead or alive." I felt my heart sink, I need to do something and I needed to do it fast.

A/N: Hi! This part was supposed to be out the day after the last one but I got really busy. I'm so sorry for it being late. I hope you all are doing good💕💕