Shawn-
His face would harden and he would be trying so hard not to go over and puch the guy in the face because you were Shawn's and no one else's. Shawn would be very protective over you but he would know that you didn't like it when he constantly tried to protect you so he would clench his jaw and just give the guy a death glare until he walked away leaving you confused. You would then turn around and see Shawn and and you would raise your eyebrows at him saying, 'really' and he would shrug with a sheepish smile that said 'what? I didn't do anything' and you would playfully roll your eyes and to him "You're lucky I love you!"
Aaron-
He would give the guy a disgusted look that said 'why the hell are you talking to my girl?' and he wouldn't look away, making him uncomfortable until he left. Then he would come up behind you and say "Who was that babe?" and you would reply "I don't know you're stare scared him off before he could introduce himself" And then he would kiss your head and say "good"
Cam-
Cam would practically kill the guy with his stare. He would have to grab the table or something to keep himself from walking over there and making sure the guy knew you were his. He would proably leave some dents or marks on the table by the time you had finished talking with the guy.
Nash-
Nash would be confused and angry if he saw you with another guy. He would like 'why is (Y/N) talking to another guy?' to the guys and they would look back at him like 'dude chill' and he would just silently watch you guys with this expression, making sure that he didn't do anything.
Jack J-
Johnson would just casually get a baseball bat or any harmful object and stand behind you without knowing as you talked to the guy and he would eye the guy like 'you see this in my hand, yeah you're going to see it a lot closer when I swing it at your face.' and the guy would practically run off. You would turn around to see Johnson and you would playfully roll your eyes.
Jack G-
Jack wouldn't even bother giving the guy a look. He would come right up to you, give you a passionate kiss, and wrap his arm around you with his hand on your butt, look at the guy and directly say "No" and the guy would just walk away. You would look up at him. "At this rate I won't have any guy friend" you tell him "I'm completly fine with that" He would say and you would playfully hit him and laugh.
Matt-
He would have to low key meditate to himself and pray that he would be able to control himself. Matt may seem very playful but when it comes to you he would be really overprotective of you, but only because he loves you and doesn't want anyone else to have you.
Hayes-
He would just stare at him like 'yeah that's right stay away from my girl' The guy would get so uncomfortable that he couldn't conduct a decent conversation with you and he just embarrased himself in front of you which made Hayes very happy.
Taylor-
Taylor would just be like "what the fuck are you doing bro, you know I will kill you." like it is the most obvious thing in the world. Taylor would be super over protective and wrap his arms aroud you and say "no she's mine."
Carter-
Carter would look at the guy like 'use your head is this really logical decision to try and talk to my girl?' Then he would sling his arm around your shoulder and you would rest your head on his shoulder as you scoffed and dramatically sigh. "You do this every time" You say but you were amused and flattered at how over protective he was of you. "And I will do this every time" He says with a smirk and then kissed you on the forehead.
