Never Gonna Give You Up

Pool Day pt. 2

Y/N's POV:

Dev and Anna joined us in the pool and we played Marco Polo. The little boy's name was Oliver and we called him Ollie, the sisters name was Kelly, and the oldest brother's name was Liam. While playing with the kids, I noticed Eva and the girls staring. They weren't staring at Anna or Dev, they were focused on me. Every once in a while I would get out of the pool and throw the kids in because they thought it was fun. When I got out, I see the girls turn to each other and talk like a bunch of high schoolers. I'm not sure if they're saying good things, commenting about my body, or something else.

While the girls were talking and the kids were playing with Dev and Anna, I decided to swim by them.

"So... what are the prettiest girls at the resort talking about?" I said as I splashed some of them.

"Y/N!!! You got my hair wet!!" Cynthia said,

"Sorry" I replied.

I see Eva giggle at the corner of my eye and said,

"What are you laughing about???"

She stopped laughing and had a worried look as I went closer to her.

I picked her up and out of the hot tub... walking towards the pool and that's when she stated to squirm, kick, and beg for me to not throw her in the pool.

"Y/N PLEASE I'M BEGGIN YOU!!! DON'T THROW ME IN THE POOL!!!"

"THROW HER IN!!!" Anna yelled,

"SHUT UP ANNA!!!" Eva said,

I throw Eva in the pool and see all the girls laughing.

"So... Who's next????" I shout and all the girls start getting out of the hot tub.

"Oh stop whining, the pool is heated" Anna said,

I managed to get Cynthia and Tori and throw them in the pool and when Sab saw me get out again, she just gave up and jumped in.

The kids were having a blast and I noticed Ollie at the edge of the pool. I swam over to him and started talking to him.

"Hey buddy, you okay?"

"mhm" he replied softly,

"Alright... what's going on??" I ask

"Well I don't want to be in floaties anymore. I'm a big boy!"

"Yeah??? You want me to teach you how to swim??" I ask,

I saw a big smile come across his face and he rips the floaties off his arms.

Eva's POV:

After getting thrown in the pool, I had no other choice, but to play with the kids and have some fun with the girls. Y/N was playing with little Ollie and the rest of the girls were playing with Liam and Kelly.

"Sab??? Can I talk to you?" I ask her and pull her to where Y/N and the girls can't hear us.

"Yeah, what's up??"

"I really like Y/N and she has said that she's a lesbian, but I'm not sure how I would show that I like her. Like she's so good with Ollie and the kids, and it makes me want kids with her"

"All I can say is that the other girls and I like Y/N too. She is perfect for you. Just be brave and go for it" Sab replied,

Before I get a chance to talk to Y/N, the kids' parents show up and Y/N heads over towards them. The other girls come towards me and I feel like this is the time I should ask for their opinion.

"Hey girls, I had a question... what do you guys think about Y/N?"

"I like her a lot!" Dev chimed in,

"Yeah me too, she's so good with kids" Tori said,

"I agree, she also has a great body" Cynthia said,

"And a great personality!" Sab finished off.

The only person who didn't say anything and just nodded was Anna. She had a sad look to her face and I wasn't sure what's going on. The most important opinion to me was Anna's because she's my best friend.

"Anna?? What do you think about Y/N?"

"Well to be honest, I feel like she's too perfect"

"What do you mean?" I questioned,

"Well what flaws have we seen?? All we've seen is that she's super nice, an incredible athlete, great with kids, has a nice body, has a great personality, is generous. She wasn't even bothered that her trip got crashed by 6 girls and got run over by Eva a thousand times" She said,

Now that she's said all this, I'm starting to think that this is too good to be true. Anna's right, We haven't seen any flaws with Y/N. I mean we only met her 2 days ago.

"Eva... don't listen to her. We've only met the girl for 2 days. Her flaws will come out eventually. I say go for it" Tori said,

"I agree, but if she hurts you, she's getting her ass kicked" Cynthia followed,

"Are you sure?? I don't know. I mean Anna is right, but also Cynthia's right too" I said,

"Maybe she's just making a good impression because she likes you Eva... or maybe she's just that good of a person" Dev said.

Before anyone could say anything else, Y/N swam over to us.

"Hey... you guys hungry???" she asked,

I looked at the girls and most of us said yes. We all got changed and like we did for lunch, we decided to meet in the lobby. Y/N was waiting with Anna and from what I saw, Anna was grilling her. I'm not sure what's going on with her, but I have a feeling she's not too happy about me liking Y/N.

"Hey Anna! Hey Y/N!" I said as I gave Y/N a hug.

Anna looked annoyed so I pulled her to the side.

"What's up with you?? And don't tell me that you think Y/N is too perfect. We've only known the girl for 2 days"

"I can't say it cause I don't want to ruin our friendship" she said and walked away.

When the rest of the girls come down, Anna starts walking back to the rooms.

"Boon?? Where are you going??" Sab asks,

"Back to the rooms, I don't feel like going out anymore" Anna replies

"Do you want us to bring you anything back?" I ask,

She stays silent.

"Anna!!" Y/N yells out and runs towards her.

"Hey!!! I'm sorry if I did anything to offend you or hurt you, but that doesn't mean you should ignore your friends." I hear her yell out.

Y/N's POV:

As I was chasing after Anna, she started to walk faster. I didn't know what was going on and I wasn't sure how she was gonna eat so I had to stop her and say something.

"Anna!!!"

"Hey!! I'm sorry if I did anything to offend you or hurt you, but that doesn't mean you should ignore your friends" I say.

She stops and looks at me annoyed.

"I'm not offended and you didn't do anything. That's the thing, you don't do anything bad!!! All you've done is take Eva away from me. None of the girls know, but I like Eva... more than a friend. And I can't do anything because I don't want to ruin our friendship and she likes you!" she says loud enough for only me to hear.

A/N
Hey guys!!! Sorry to leave you on a cliff hanger, but I had to do smt to spice it up a bit. I know Anna and Eva don't like each other in that way irl and are tired of people shipping them together, but it's only for a little bit. They will go back to being normal friends with no tension and awkwardness in my story.