PLL Theories

Alison twin theory. (Bethany Young)

In my last Update I said something about The Police finding Alison's body. Everyone is sure that it is Bethany Young because Ali is back... Or is she? After Alison is back, the Police and the liars have no choice but to find another person who can be in the grave, so they chose Bethany Young. How could Bethany be in her grave without the Police realising? Alison and Bethany should be VERY similar. I wonder why, maybe because they are TWINS? Okay so let's start from 'That Night'. I believe that Bethany was signed out of Radley, by Mrs D (Or Mrs Fitz, see one of my last posts) and ran away from her. She ran to see Alison because she was angry at her. The tape that Mona and Spencer found of Bethany saying that someone is an 'Evil Bitch' was about Alison and she wanted revenge. So she ran to Mrs D's house to find Alison. So Bethany followed Alison around everywhere she said she was in the season 4 finale and when she finally came back to Spencer's barn Bethany went behind Alison as she was going home from the barn and attacked her. Alison won the fight and she didn't know who it was. Bethany was unconscious and Alison thought that she killed her so she went to her back yard and buried her Alive. However, Mrs Granwald (I don't know if I spelt it right, please forgive meh) came and thought that it was Alison reaching for life when it was actually Bethany. Mrs Granwald took her out and drove her to the Hospital but Bethany escaped to finish Alison off. She went back to the DiLaurentis house and saw Alison in front of her house and hit her with a rock. Mrs D saw her and covered for her as she Mrs D's daughter so she buried Alison. Bethany ran away and became Red Coat and ruled the -A team to find out as much as she can about Alison and her life so she could come back like nothing happened. She made up the whole journey. She remember what happened 'That Night' to Alison as she followed her everywhere and she knew everything about the girls as she worked with Mona.

In the picture that I added you can see the scene where Jason gives 'Alison' a photo from a horrible day and she remembers it like it was a nice day. Everyone tells her she isn't a good liar anymore. Maybe Bethany never was a good liar?
That's my theory! Sorry this was long 😴