PLL Theories

Bethany is Charles part 2. (Analizing the twin story 2x13)

So I had a talk with my brother ( who doesn't watch pll but he knows half the things coz I keep talking about it) and this theory came up. It's a theory of where Alison has heard the twin story she told Hanna is the first ever Halloween episode. This also fits in with my 'Bethany is Charles' theory.

So, we know Bethany was locked up in Radley because of anger issues and we also know that Bethany and Alison talked to each other, now this is what I think happened:
- If you read my Bethany Is Charles theory you saw that I think Charles/ Bethany was sent to Radley because s/he did something bad to Alison ( That broken arm she broke when she was three?) or tried doing something bad to her.
- Charles/ Bethany had anger issues so I'm guessing s/he was making up stories about what s/he could do to Alison and how to hurt her.
- Bethany /Charles wanted to have Alison's life or wanted to look like Alison so s/he made a story about them being twins and the twin that kills in the story is Bethany/Charles and the twin that gets murdered is Alison.
- When visiting Bethany in Radley Bethany/Charles tells her the story without admitting that it is about her and how much s/he hates her.

I want to thank you guys for getting me to nearly 2k views on this book! I love all of you and hope you had an amazing Easter! 💕💕