PLL Theories

Charles is Bethany

So here's my Charles is Bethany theory:
The boys in the video obviously had an age difference. We know Jason is one of the boys in the video and I'm guessing he is the older one. We see how the younger one (Probably Charles) tries to get Mrs D's attention by showing her apples but she is too busy with Alison. Maybe that's how it was all the time. Maybe he wanted to be like Alison to get his mothers attention. He then wanted Alison gone as she took his Mother away from him. He might have tried to do something bad to Alison ( for example break her arm... Remember, she broke her arm when she was 3 and it never really healed?) and then he became so obsessed with hurting Alison in anyway possible that they sent him away to another family. If you google Bethany Young it says she grew up in a place 10 minutes from Rosewood. So I'm guessing Charles/ Bethany got sent away at a young age. Then maybe Charles was so obsessed with Alison he wanted to be her, so he had a sex change. S/he started dressing like her and talking like her. Then after it became really bad the family that adopted her/him told Mrs DiLaurentis and she started visiting Bethany and all that, then Bethany found out that Mrs D is actually her mother and got mad when she wouldn't admit it and made Bethany call her Auntie Jessie. Alison and Bethany became Pen Pals and when Bethany escaped Radley on Labor Day she looked in a window of the barn and saw how much fun Alison is having and she hated her because Alison took the life that Bethany/Charles could have. S/he also hated her friends as they were so good to her (Remember s/he had a mental illness so s/he could have hated anyone for small reasons) and that's why s/he started targeting them.