Red Dead Redemption 2 x Reader Scenarios [hiatus]

How they told Dutch/Hosea that you two are together

Since Dutch and Hosea are basically the dads to most of them, I figure some of them would tell them about it and ask for their advice.

Arthur:

Oh, Dutch and Hosea knew the second they saw you two sitting aside each other that you two were together, but they said nothing about it. And damn were they happy they didn't because seeing how Arthur was flustered, trying to tell them about it, was a very amusing sight they both enjoyed. Dutch even eventually began helping Arthur say it, to which Arthur froze and gave them unimpressed eyes, saying, "You both already know, don't you?", to which the two shrugged carelessly with amused smiles so Arthur stormed away, embarrassed he made a fool out of himself.

John:

He didn't mind telling Hosea, he knew Hosea would be supportive and maybe even ask some advice since he seen Hosea and Bessie and he always wanted to have such a relationship like them because their relationship was filled with so much happiness and love. But Dutch is what scared him, he was convinced Dutch wouldn't even listen and say no, so he was extremely shocked when Dutch pat him on the back and told him he found a good one and he better treats you right, even joking that they should break out some beer to celebrate.

Dutch:

Hosea means a lot to Dutch, maybe even more than you, as sad as that is to hear. Hosea and Dutch have a bond that is so special and unique so if Hosea were to disapprove, just know that Dutch will rethink this whole relationship and start to doubt it. So you were both lucky that Hosea approved, telling Dutch with a chuckle that he shouldn't ask approval from him, to which Dutch told him with a chuckle that he means a lot to him so of course he needed it.

Hosea:

Hosea was a bit nervous, hoping Dutch doesn't judge you and even scare you away. It was while the two were having a drink that Dutch noticed Hosea kept drumming his finger so he asked him what's wrong and Hosea twirled his bottle, debating if he should do it now or not. He decided he might as well and asked Dutch if he would be okay with him and you dating. Dutch put his bottle down, saying he's fine with whatever makes him happy. Dutch did ask him if he doesn't feel as if he's betraying Bessie, to which Hosea let out a sad sigh and mumbled he does feel like that sometimes but he truly loves you and he knows Bessie wouldn't want him to mope around.

Charles:

He didn't tell either, he didn't see why he should tell them about his love life. His love life is his, not theirs.

Javier:

He sat on the log when he noticed Dutch walking across the camp so he quickly got up and jogged over, calling him before casually asking how he would feel if he and you began dating, doing a little hand gesture as if to ask "would you approve or disapprove". Dutch just chuckled and pat his shoulder, telling him he thinks it is beautiful to see young people in love. Javier took that as approval and nod, saying that's good before he went back to the log, happy Dutch approves of it.

Kieran:

Of course he didn't tell either of them. He told nobody really, he knows they will just tease and make dumb jokes about it so he kept it to himself.

Mary-Beth:

She said it to Hosea while she was daydreaming, talking about her novels, saying how she hopes she can do such romantic things from the novels with you. At this Hosea raised his eyebrow before smiling, a bit amused, asking why she and you would do such things, to which Mary-Beth blushed as she shyly said you and her have been dating for a few months now and she absolutely adores you. So she happily told Hosea about you before blushing again, apologizing for rambling about you, which made Hosea chuckle and say it's okay and young people in love are a nice thing to see so he doesn't mind.

Sadie:

She didn't tell them. When you asked if they shouldn't know, she huffed out a "fuck them" and said this is her relationship and she barely knows them so they don't have to know about such personal stuff.