Red Dead Redemption 2 x Reader Scenarios [hiatus]

When someone suspicious asks for their help so you shake your head to them

The title might be a bit confusing: You are shaking your head to your lover, not the stranger.

The title really is "When someone suspicious asks them for their help so you shake your head to them to signal not to help this stranger", but obviously that title is way too long for the short titles Wattpad allows.

Arthur:

He wasn't planning to help. That's until the person said he will be paid, but when you shook your head, he declined. He couldn't help but groan and roll his eyes as the person immediately reached for their gun when he declined, but Arthur was faster and shot them first, asking with a sigh why he always meets weird folk.

John:

He was already leaning away from the weird person, glancing at you and almost giving you unimpressed eyes that you think you would need to shake your head at him for him to know not to go with this person. He told the person to find someone else to help them then took your hand and walked away.

Dutch:

He just watched this person, wondering how much more obvious they can be that they are planning something dangerous. When he noticed you shaking your head, he gave you this look that told you not to worry because he will deal with it. He wasn't in the mood for any serious trouble now so he just forced a smile and wrapped his arm around you, saying he was about to take his lover out for a date so they will have to excuse you two then he dragged you away in a hurry. Once far away, he laughed about it.

Hosea:

He just awkwardly glanced at the person then you, wearing this "is this person serious?" look, knowing if they follow this person some weird danger will happen. You shook your head making him chuckle because he couldn't agree more. As the person looked away, pointing to somewhere, Hosea took your hand and both sneaked away in a hurry. Both hid behind a building, snickering as you both watched the person twirling around, trying to find you two.

Charles:

He just gave a firm sorry but no, already knowing this is gonna lead to danger. He was glad to see you shaking your head because that assured him he doesn't have to worry that you would follow such a suspicious person just because they are asking for help. But the person chuckled and said such a strong man can definitely help him out. Charles gave you this "this person is annoying" look so you nod in agreement. Charles just pulled out his knife, not actually gonna attack but just to show he's armed and won't hesitate to attack if the person tries anything. It seemed to work because the person stumbled away then ran off.

Javier:

He just let out a "huh?" as they asked for his help, glancing to you. You shook your head his way. He doesn't mind helping some people but he wasn't gonna help nor follow some suspicious person like this. So instead he had his fun with them, acting as if he doesn't know English and just annoying the person by asking them to repeat what they said, saying in Spanish he doesn't understand what they want. He kept doing this until they stormed away in annoyance, to which he just laughed.

Kieran:

He felt nervous as he nervously stuttered out he cannot help. As the person said he doesn't know until he sees what the problem is though, Kieran awkwardly laughed and said that's true but he still thinks he can't really help. He looked at you, now starting to worry if he should just go and help so they can leave you two alone, but you shook your head so Kieran whispered sorry but no and then took your hand and hurried away before the person can continue pressuring him.

Mary-Beth:

She felt a bit nervous, taking your hand, awkwardly saying she doubts a fragile lady like her can help them out with anything. As the person kept pressuring, she glanced to you so you shook your head to tell her not to help them then pulled her away, firmly telling the stranger that neither of you will help them so they better just go ask someone else. Mary-Beth worried the person might not leave but luckily they stormed off with a huff.

Sadie:

She gave a "what the fuck" to the person before telling them no and took your hand and began walking, only to groan as they followed, too stubborn to give up. She turned and shouted she said no so they better leave before they have one of her bullets through their head.