Killer (Ticci Toby x Reader)

682 18 4
                                    

          Hello my friends! So here’s a small one-shot between Toby and Reader-Chan! This song is honestly one of my favorites, because murder! Hype! Seriously though, enjoy!

                                                                   ~Silver

WARNING: SADNESS AND DEATH AHEAD

 

Key:

(y/n) – Your name

Italics – Song lyrics

 

 

Stuck in a limbo (here we go)

Me and my sins go (toe-to-toe oh oh oh)

I played a vicious part (whoa)

I broke an unfair share of hearts

I’m about to blow

So if you come around then you should know

 

Toby knew it was wrong to fall in love with a human, it was unheard of. A CreepyPasta, let alone a proxy, was not supposed to love their targets. So when Toby found himself in that situation, he didn’t know what to do.

I’ll tear you up in two

Go ahead walk it off if you know whats best for you

Oh-oh-oh-oh oh oh

 

You loved Toby as well. The two of you had met when he was supposed to kill you, however you had instead offered him waffles as you were eating them at the time. He reluctantly accepted and was planning on killing you afterwards, however he had found you intriguing and didn’t do it. You were aware that he wasn’t allowed to love you, but you couldn’t help yourself.

I’m no good for you (no)

This heart ain’t built for two so

Runaway, runaway

Cuz I’m no, I’m no, I’m no good for you

I’m no good for you (no)

Get in love then I’ll bet you lose so

Runaway, runaway

Cuz I’m no, I’m no, I’m no good for you

Imma imam imma love killer

Imma imam imma love killer

Imma imam imma killer

 

Toby was unstable, always was, always will be. You had known this to, and it was a part of him that you loved. What was the point in being sane if it was no fun and you got bullied because of it? You wanted to join Toby and the rest of the Pastas, however he was extremely reluctant to let you do so. If he did, you’d most likely be killed before you even set foot in the mansion.

Lower than real low (here we go)

Take your heart like a repo (no-no-no-oh-oh)

One-Shots (Reader Inserts)Where stories live. Discover now