The Sandlot Boys (FEM x-reader)

How Could He?

Y/N POV

We all just stood there staring at Benny. The boys and I were seething with anger, except for  Tommy, he was crying into my shoulder. I held him tighter and rubbed his back as I glared at Benny. He was looking at us, and was standing as though he was paralyzed. Michelle followed his eyes, and turned to see us. Unlike Benny though, when she looked at us -me, she smirked and waved. 

I scoffed and rolled my eyes, but soon turned back to Benny. It seemed as though he woke up from a trance, because just then he looked at Michelle and then back to us. He gave an awkward smile, and grabbed her hand. It was like he was telling us they were together. Like um no shit, you just kissed her! We got the hint! 

I shook my head and turned to look at the boys, Tommy specifically. He's the one who just got beat up. I swear if I see those guys again, I'm going t-. My thoughts were cut off by a teacher pushing the nine of us off the stage. I held Tommy tighter and motioned for the boys to follow me out. I don't know about them, but I knew that I didn't want to be there anymore, and by the looks of it, neither did the others. We walked out of the school and on to the pavement. We heard footsteps, so we instinctively turned around. Low and behold Benny 'the jet' Rodriguez was standing there along with the backstabbing witch herself- I mean  Michelle. :) I rolled my eyes for probably the twentieth time this evening.  I shooed him away with my hand, and gave him a sarcastic smile, thinking he would get the hint but he didn't move. 

I looked at the boys wide eyed, as if to say 'why are they still here?'. They had the same look plastered on their faces. 

"I can't believe I actually have to say this, but Benny we are trying to tell you to leave." 

I said annoyed. I had a right to be. He kissed a bully, and not just any bully at that. OUR BULLY.  he sighed and turned to whisper something to "her", ugh I mentally gag at just the thought of her name. She huffed and reluctantly left us alone, to what I assume is talk. 

"Look, I know that you are mad."

Benny whispered. 

"Mad is an understatement!" 

Smalls yelled. We all nodded in agreement. Scotty walked forward from our little circle to stand closer to Benny. 

"You we're literally kissing the worst person we know!"

"I-"

"No! You don't get to talk Benny!" 

Timmy spoke up. 

"You know about what she's done to all of us, and you still go and date her!"  

Kenny chimed in. 

"I thought you were better than this Benny. We are your friends- no your family. You don't betray your family." 

Ham said calmly, but his voice cracked at the end. 

"Yeah, yeah Benny! I looked up to you and you, you , you go and do this!" 

Yeah- yeah remarked. 

"I can't believe after everything, you would still choose her." 

Bertie muttered under his breath. 

"It's messed up man!" 

Squints yelled. Tommy and I stayed silent, so after the others spoke they looked to me. I knew they were telling me if I wanted to talk I could. I nodded but first whispered into Tommy's ear. 

"Do you have something you want to say to Benny?" 

I whispered. He shook his head no while sniffling. I nodded and looked up at Benny.