The Day I'd Never Forget

Chapter 14

Levi caressed my thighs while looking up at me seductively.

"We're taking things slowly..remember?"

I nodded and bit my lip, letting him continue with what he was doing.
With moans escaping from me, Levi quickly put one of his hands over my mouth to contain them from echoing through the thin walls of the dorms. I forced myself to quiet down so I wouldn't wake anyone up who was sleeping, although it was hard..
The pleasure Levi gave me so far was enough to make me scream, yet I was holding it all in. Scary part was, I knew this wasn't all he could do to make me feel this way..
Or anyone, for that matter.

Being a virgin, of course I didn't know what penetration felt like..
Only penetration I ever experienced was fingering by myself. Not by anything..."big".
Just imagining Levi penetrating me drove me crazy on the inside..turning me on every time I thought about it happening.

I could feel him leaving his slick, smooth saliva all over my asshole, even inserting his tongue inside me from time to time. He'd do it out of nowhere on purpose to surprise me when I least expected it.
The teasing..the calming yet strong sensations he gave me...I wanted more..

I felt my wish was about to be granted as soon as Levi lifted his head to look up at me.

"Want me to go further...?"

I nodded nervously, giving him the signal to proceed.

 Levi let go of my legs and began to crawl on top of me. Letting him take more control of me, I lied there and watched as his body heat continued to heat me up. 

"Are you sure you can take me?"

I hesitated to answer him as my eyes shifted to his 8 inch member, which was now positioned at the entrance of my hole. 

After a few seconds of thinking to myself, I looked back up at Levi, who was directly on top of me now with his face only an inch away from mine.

"Yes I'm sure now.."

He smirked and placed his hand on his dick, stroking it slowly while looking into my eyes.

"What a brave one you are.." He said as he placed his erect dick at the entrance of my tight asshole.

He began to push into me slowly and with caution. The more he pushed, the more I tensed up. I was able to get through the first few seconds of pain without yelping. Even though I was lubed, it still felt like an entire fist was being pushed into me..

When Levi had his entire tip inside me, he stopped and looked at me.

"You okay?"

I nodded slowly and opened my eyes from having them shut tight. 

"I'm fine..you can keep going.."

Levi then went ahead and pushed half of his size into me, pushing my limit.

"AH!"

He stopped and looked down at me with a shocked and concerned expression. That yelp was rather loud.
"Eren..let's stop for now okay?"

"No! I can take it..I just have to get used to it.."

"You're sure..?"

"Please..just keep going.."

Levi placed his right hand over my mouth to keep me from making noise as he continued to push slowly. I winced in pain and clenched the sheets of my bed tightly, having to bear the pain of him stretching me out.

But over time..the pain began to ease up, allowing me to loosen up from being so tense. Once Levi saw that I was easing into it, he removed his hand from my mouth and held his balance on me. His member was now almost all the way inside me as I could feel it hitting my most sensitive spot already. I moaned softly in pleasure, signaling him to push the rest in.

As Levi pushed the rest of his dick inside of me letting the base of it meet my ass, I moaned a bit louder.

"Shush Jaeger."

"I-it's starting to feel good.."

"I know it is. Why do you think I made us lube each other first?"

I didn't fully think of it until he muttered those words that he plotted to use our saliva on each other as lube.

"Can I move..?"

"Y-yes.."