All Figured Out || Archer x Reader

Spoiler Alert: He DOES Like Starbucks

cw: cursing
—

Y/N just stared at the mark. They didn't say anything. They didn't want to, honestly. Why.... how..?! Y/N swore they didn't bite it themselves... unless it was during their sleep.. but why would they do that? It was unlikely Y/N moved around during their sleep a lot anyways. They tried to not think about it and excused it for being something like a bug bite - because sure, bugs had that sharp of teeth. They continued the day like usual.

They put on a yellow and white t-shirt with jean shorts. Surprisingly enough, it was gonna be warm today! Thank god Spring is starting. Anyhow, they put on their f/c shoes before heading out to classes. On the way, guess who they ran in to?! That's right. The bastard himself, Archer. "Oh! Hey, Archer." Archer waved and smiled. "What's up, Y/N, darling?" Y/N laughed. "Oh, you know. The usual." Y/N replied with causality. "Nice! Same for me, so, that's cool. I'm just gonna head to Starbucks before class, wanna come along? I'll pay for it,"

Y/N pretty much almost visibly pogged. Was he... inviting you to Starbucks??? And he was gonna?? Pay for it?? What a gentleman. Of course Y/N had to agree. "For real?! Sure!" Archer nodded as a reply before taking Y/N's hand and began walking to the local Starbucks. Y/N was trying to process this all at once. This was fiiiiiiiiine. As Y/N and Archer made their way to the local Starbucks, they both noticed it was packed with people around their age. It made sense, courses didn't usually start until later in the day and students had some time to kill. It also made sense with the fact it was the morning, and the local teens couldn't survive without their morning coffee!

Something Y/N also noticed - two familiar faces - Eleanor and Aoife! Y/N quickly walked over to them, Archer's hand still in theirs, and said their hellos. "I didn't know you guys would be here!" Y/N remarks. Instead of informing Y/N that they have told them many times they go there in the morning, they stare at them. Then at Archer. Then back at Y/N.

"You and Archer are dating?!?!" Eleanor spits out, noticing their hands conjoined. Y/N looked awkward as hell while Archer just.. lightheartedly chuckled. Y/N didn't say a word. As they continued to chat a bit before ordering their drinks, Aoife pointed out the bite mark on Y/N's hand. "What's that all about?" They said, pointing at it. Archer visibly cringed while Y/N nodded. "Yeah uh.. it kinda appeared there last night. I dunno, it was kinda strange"

Archer, like Y/N a couple minutes ago, tried not to say anything. Hm.. it's almost like the bastard had bitten it himself!!! "Yeah that's.. weir...d" Eleanor and Aoife slowly looked at Archer. They were onto him. For sure. Y/N glanced at him too after his silence pretty much said enough about it. "Look, I didn't bite Y/N! They have never even told me where they live before, so how do you guys think I did-?!"

"Oi, shut up sunflower boy! We know what you're up to!" Y/N restrained themself to not go livid at Eleanor for that one. "Oh, come on. Y/N, you believe me, right? I didn't do it?" He says, staring into Y/N eyes. Part two of Archer taking notes on Y/N's emotions and facial expressions. Y/N struggled to come up with an answer, they just had their mouth open, awaiting a response, but alas, it just never happened.

"Y/N you're being crazy! Why would you trust him?! He got in a fight on the first day!" Eleanor growled out at Y/N. Archer looked at Y/N and frowned. "Y/N...? Do you.. believe me..? I promise I didn't do it!" Puppy dog eyes activate! Instantly, Y/N couldn't help but feel.. weakened by them. Eleanor and Aoife just looked at them like they were crazy.

"You gotta believe us, Y/N! This guy's not right! Just look at him!"
After that, words all seemed like a blur to Y/N, they were in their own head now, unable to return to reality for a couple seconds. Who do I chose? Who is right?.. it's Archer probably but no... it doesn't... it doesn't make any sense... please, god...

What do I do?