Beauty and the Geek

Eleven

"Sorry. I didn't mean to scare you," he said. My back was pressed to the closed refrigerator door, Randy stepped closer to me, putting his hand beside my head. "Can I ask you something?" He said. I nodded my head, looking up at him, "Yeah, of course," I said. My heart was beating so fast I wondered if he could hear it. "Why me? If you can get any guy here, like that assface, Eric Holden. But you flirt with me like all the time. So why?" He asked. I opened my mouth but nothing came out. "Cat for you tongue? I saw you flirting with him. Laughing at his stupid jokes. The dude is dumber than a rock." One hand went to my waist and I was pretty sure I was about to melt into a puddle. 

"So? Why me? I'm just a geek who is into horror way too much." I shrugged and just stared at him. This was a little out of character for Randy. I've seen him flirt with Sid and sometimes other girls but not like this. "You see me for who I am. Not as some prize to be won. People like Eric only see a pussy they can sink their dicks into," I finally said. "Do you plan on letting him fuck you?" He asked. There was something in his voice. Maybe jealousy. I shook my head. He got really close to me, lips pressed to my ear. "Good. Because you're mine now," he whispered. 

"What about Sidney?" I asked. "What about Sidney? She's an old crush. I only made it seem like I still liked her. I needed to be a hundred percent sure you liked me back and weren't just fucking with me," he said. "I better not see you flirting with anyone else. Especially fucking Jason." He pulled me closer and a gasp left me. "I agree with Billy. You shouldn't be wearing this. I mean don't get me wrong, you look hot in it but I don't want other guys looking at what's mine." Then he just walked away. 

I just looked at the door that led back into the house. "What the fuck just happened?" I whispered to myself. 

I just saw a whole different side to Randy Meeks, the geeky horror kid. And I have to say I liked it. My soaked panties were proof of that. "Hey, there you are. I've been looking for you." I rolled my eyes and walked passed Eric, "as if," I said and shut the door on my way back inside, leaving him in the garage. Randy was right, the kids is dumber than a rock. 

I walked into the living room to see Tatum in Stu's lap sitting on the chair. Billy, Sid, and Randy were on the couch and others were sitting on the floor. "What're we watching?" I asked. I moved around everyone and sat between Billy and Randy. "Sleepaway camp," Randy said, putting an arm around my shoulders. Billy nudged me and I glared, pushing him back. Stu winked at me and I flipped him off with a sarcastic smile. Everyone one was either high, drunk or had a buzz. A good amount of people had left and the only ones who stayed were the ones who wanted to watch the movies. Sunday it would be me, Stu, and Billy on this couch having our regular movie night. 

~•~•~•~ 

More people left now leaving only the six of us. Tatum and Sidney both passed out halfway through the second movie. I was half asleep my head on Randy's shoulder. "You guys wanna stay over? It's already midnight," Stu said with Tatum up in his arms heading for the stairs. Billy looked at Sidney turn over to look  at me. "You wanna stay or go home?" He asked. "We can stay," I told him. He nodded and gently woke Sidney up. "Do you want me to drive you home? Or do you wanna stay here?" He asked. She looked around and saw Stu holding a sleeping Tatum. "I'm staying at Tatum's so i'll just stay here," she said. "What about you, Meeks?" Stu asked. Randy turned his head towards him, "everyone else is staying so I may as well stay too." Stu nodded and headed up the stairs. "Sleep where ever!" 

Billy stood up mumbling he'd be right back and walked off. Me and Sindey moved closer to each other and then my eyes drifted shut. 

BILLY

When I came back from the bathroom Y/N and Sidney were curled up together sleeping. "You got Y/N?" I asked Randy. He looked over at me and nodded his head as he stood up. "Alright. You can take the guest room. If you touch my sister in anyway she doesn't want you to, I will fucking kill you next." He rolled his eyes and gently picked my sister up. 

I would have never thought that Meeks was capable of killing anyone. But he proved himself the night he helped me and Stu kill Nate. It wasn't a surprise he figured out who killed Casey and Steve. But it was a surprise when he came to us and said he wanted to help kill Nate and Jason. He didn't know about the real plan. And I was starting to question that plan. But I wasn't going to call it off. It's because of her slut mother that mine and Y/N's mom left. 

"I'm not going to do anything to her, Billy. Fucking Christ." I picked Sidney up and we walked up the stairs. I went to Stu's parents room and laid Sidney down before I went to the guest bedroom. Randy was taking off Y/N's boots. "She has nightmares and they've gotten worse since the attack at Casey's," I told him. That's my fault. She's always had nightmares since we were kids but I made them worse by what me and Stu did. "And I already know that it's my fault they're worse now. But um... just hold her if she wakes up from one. And if she asks for me, come wake me up." I pulled my shirt over my head and threw it at him. 

"Wake her and tell her to change into that. It should help," I said. He nodded, "You're a good brother, Billy. She's lucky to have you. But I promise I'm not going to let anything happen to her. I've already proven that. I'm not just some geek," he said. "Just don't fucking hurt her or you're dead. I'm trusting you with the most important person in my life besides Sid." With that I walked back to the room with Sidney. 

Y/N

I groaned as someone shook me awake. "Hmm?" I hummed. "Hey, you need to change." I opened my eyes to see Randy standing beside the bed. "Come on. Billy left his shirt for you to put on," he said. I sat up and lifted the mesh top over my head and put Billy's shirt on then slid my skirt off. I crawled under the blankets and watched Randy strip down to his boxers. He turned the light off before he crawled into bed beside me. I curled up beside him and closed my eyes again. The smell of my brothers shirt would hopefully keep those fucking nightmares away.