Beauty and the Geek

Twelve

I stood in Billy's closet trying to decide which of his flannels I wanted to ''borrow'' for the rest of my life because I never give them back. I had sneaked into his room when he went to grab the keys to the SUV from dad's office. We were all planning to go to the mall and it didn't make any sense to drive separately when we had a vehicle that had three rooms of seats. The mall was an hour away so when everyone woke up we made plans and then Randy took Sidney and Tatum back to Tatum's place since he lives the closest to her. Then Stu came back here with Billy and me.

"What the fuck are you going?" I froze in my place. My hand was hovering over a flannel that would match my cami. I turned my head to see Billy standing by the door. "Nothing," I said, dragging the word out. "Don't even fucking think about it," he hiss through his teeth. My fingers curled around the fabric and slowly started pulling it off the hanger. "It's not like you can't spare one," I shrugged. "Are you fucking kidding me! You still haven't returned the others you've taken. Get.  Your. Hand. Off. That. Fucking. Flannel."

I snatched the material and then jumped over the bed when he came towards me. Once he was away from the door I ran. "I fucking swear to god, y/n!" Billy yelled. "You better not let Mrs. Curtis hear you swear to god!" I yelled back and ran down the stairs. "You better hope I don't fucking catch you!" Stu was in the kitchen digging around in the fridge like he always does. "Stu, help me!" I said and hid behind him. "What?" He asked confused until Billy came into the kitchen. "You're not stealing anymore of my clothes. Get your own flannels," he said.

I leaned around Stu as I pulled the flannel on. "Yeah, but yours are already worn in and comfy. A new one would be too stiff," I said. "You can't hide behind Stu all day," Billy told me. "Watch me," I said. "You are such a fucking brat," he groaned. "You love me though so..." I shrugged. Billy glared at me and I gave him an innocent smile. "Aww.. look how adorable she is, Billy. You can't say no to that face," Stu said. "Shut up, Stu. You always fall intp her traps," Billy told him. He leaned against the counter and shook his head. "If you don't give it back tonight we're going to have issues," he said, pointing at me. I wouldn't give it back. It would end up in the back of my closet like the rest.

I raced past Stu, grabbing my bag on the way, "Shotgun!" I yelled and ran out of the house. "No! That's not fair!" Stu yelled, running after me. I could hear Billy cursing about how childish we were.

~•~•~•~

We picked up Tatum and Sidney first and while waiting for them to come out I climbed over the seats, hitting Stu in the head on the way to the very back. "Ow! Easy," he said, rubbing his head. "Oops. By bad," I said. "You two are fucking children. Both of you behave," Billy said. "Someone's in a bad mood," I whispered to Stu as I leaned forward. "So grumpy," he said. Billy turned and glared at us, "Well, If someone would stop stealing my shit I wouldn't be in a bad mood," he said. I pointed at myself, "Me? I'm not stealing. I'm-- borrowing," I said. "Right. Is that why I haven't gotten any of my flannels or tee-shirts back?" He asked. "I love you?" I said in a questioning tone.

"If it was anyone else he'd probably kill them," Stu said. "Yeah, but I'm his little sister. And even if he acts like a big baby— about it he doesn't really care," I said. Billy didn't make a remark as Sidney got into the front seat and Tatum got in the back to seat with Stu. Then we went to pick Randy up.

I was feeling like an idiot. I let myself believe everything he said last night was real. Everyone was drunk and drunk teenagers say and do stupid shit. So when he got into the back with me I made sure to leave as much space between us as possible. "Can we go now? I'm starving," Stu complained. "You were just snooping through our fridge before we left, Stu," I said. "Yeah, like everytime you come over," Billy told him. "Didn't find anything. You guys should go to the store," Stu said.  Billy rolled his eyes and headed through town and towards the freeway. The radio was turned up, windows down. It was a really nice day out, no clouds in sight.

RANDY

I looked over at y/n, everyone else was in their own world. She was keeping space between us, staring out the window. "Why are you so far away?" I asked, grabbing her attention. She looked over at me with raised eyebrows. "What?" She asked. "Why are you so far away?" She looked at the space between us, "because unlike Stu I know what personal space is," she said. Stu turned around acting offended, "Hey!" He said. "It's true," Tatum told him and made h8m turn around. "Well, I don't need personal space when it comes to you," I told her. I could see Billy looking at us through the rear view mirror. A"I was serious last night if that's what you're thinking about," I told Y/N.

The way she looked down and was pulling at her fingers told me that was exactly what she was thinking about. I won't lie and say it doesn't make me upset because it does. Especially after I put myself at the risk of going to jail for life.

Flashback

I walked up to Stu and Billy standing in the horror section. "I know it was you two," I said. They both turned around and looked at me. "What the fuck are you talking about?" Billy asked, glaring at me. I got closer and lowered my voice. "I know you two killed Casey and Steve. Don't try and deny it. And I know you plan to kill Nate after Tatum brought him up today. I want to help,"I told them. I've been thinking about it since earlier that day.

"Why? What do you have against him?" Stu asked. "The same thing you do. The way he fucking stares at y/n. And I've heard him say how he wants to do things to her. He thinks because she gave herself to Jason she'll give it up to him," I said. Billy's eyes filled with rage, "excuse me? What the fuck do you mean my sister gave herself to fucking Jason?" He growled, grabbing the front of my shirt. "Oh. She didn't tell you. She let him take her virginity. I heard her, Sid, and Tatum talking about it the next day. She regrets it," I told him.

Later that night after I got off work the three of us went to Nate's house. We all had these ghostface  costumes on. Billy called him while Stu and I sneaked inside. It was hard to get inside. He had the back door open and a window open. We could hear him talking to Billy on the phone telling him to fuck off. Billy must have scared him enough that he locked the door and shut the window.

Stu made a run from one side to the other just enough that Nate would she the black of hos cloak out of the corner of his eye. Stu would unlock the front door for Billy and then we would attack him. I didn't even give them a chance. As soon as I was close enough I stabbed him in the side. He stumbled back covering the wound and looked up. "Who the fuck are you?" He asked, backing up. He tried to run but Stu blocked his way. When he went to try to run the other way Billy blocked him.

We had him cornered and I lost control and stabbed him over and over. I didn't exactly go into detail about what I've heard him say about y/n. How he wanted to bend her over in her uniform and ''ruin'' her. Just the thought of his hands on her pissed me off and made me see red. Stu eventually pulled me away. We dragged him outside and Stu gut him and we hung him in the tree just like they did with Casey.

It didn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that Billy and Stu were the ones to kill Casey and Steve. Billy screams killer and Stu is his little lap dog so of course he would help. And Stu was pissed when Casey broke up with him for Steve Fucking Orth. I saw the look Billy gave y/n when Tatum brought up Nate. And when she ran off after Sidney I saw the look him and Stu shared. Y/N has always flirted with me but I always thought she was just messing with me and I liked Sidney too so it wasn't something I took serious. Well, not until the end of the junior year at least. But I still needed to make sure she wasn't just messing with me.

End

Billy and Stu both had a long talk with me after we killed Nate about not only what happened and what we had just done but they gave me a lecture and threatened me. Billy told me about y/n really liking me and Stu suggested I confess to her at the party. But then when she was at the video store helping me and started flirting while we put away the pornos, I got flustered and couldn't talk. I didn't know what to say. Not until I saw her with fucking Eric and wanted to rip his head off. The liquid courage helped a little too. Now I just need to make it very clear to her that it wasn't because I was drunk. That what I had told her last night was true. And this would have to be where I started with proving that to her.