Beauty and the Geek

Forty

BILLY

It was a shock that my father didn't blame me for what happened to y/n but it was an even bigger shock when our mother showed up. We haven't seen her in two years since the events back home in Woodsboro. I've never been scared in my life, not until I saw my sister laying in that van covered in blood. There was so much blood that it was dripping onto the ground under the van. I punched Randy until Stu and Dewey had pulled me away. He promised he would protect her. He promised he wouldn't let anything happen to her. He didn't fight back when I hit him. He just let it happen. I wanted to kill him but I knew if I did that and my sister did live she would end up killing me. And I also couldn't deny that he loves her. That was clear as day.

Sidney and Tatum were going to be taken to a safe house by the detectives that were following us around earlier. They wanted all of us to go but I wasn't leaving and it was clear neither was Randy. Stu stayed back for a little before he eventually left to go meet the girls at the safe house. It was almost three in the morning. My parents left and went to a hotel, neither of them saying a word to each other. There's an itch inside of me, one that so badly wants me to finish what I had started back in Woodsboro. I love Sidney and things have been great between us. The only problem that was getting in my way was fucking Derek.

I didn't like the dude or the way he looked at her. My plan was to kill her for what her mother did. There are days when I look at her and only see her slut of a mother. I can't help but think if she would end up like her. If she would cheat on me with every guy that looked at her. Some days I couldn't even be near her because I would get inside my head and convince myself she was fucking Derek. There have even been rare moments where I've stood over her while she slept in my bed, my knife gripped in my hand so tight my knuckles turned white. But it never went any further than that. Once I cleared my head logic came back to me and I would lay back down and pull her into my arms.

I looked over to Randy to see him asleep in the chair across the room. I stood up and stretched. The ringing of my phone made me jump a little. I was wound too tight. I pulled my phone out of my pocket and answered it. "Yeah?"

"It's going to be fun finishing the job you didn't finish."

I went still, my body tensing back up. "Who the fuck is this?" I nodded through my teeth.

"You should be thanking me, Billy. Getting rid of Sidney for you after what her mother did. You've been blinded by love. I'm doing you a favor and opening your eyes."

"I swear to god if you fucking touch one hair on her head I'll fucking kill you."

"Then you better hurry. Before I get a little stab happy."

The line went dead and I ran back into the waiting room and shook Randy awake. "What. What's wrong? Is y/n okay?" He jumped up. I grabbed him by the shoulders and forced him to look at me. "You need to stay here with y/n. Do you hear me? Don't leave her fucking side, Randy. I mean it this time. I need to go find Stu. The killer is after the girls he just called me." His eyes bulged out of his eyes as he looked at me. "Do you understand me? Don't leave her fucking side!" I shook him. He nodded and I took off for the stairs. I wasn't waiting for the fucking elevator.

The hospital wasn't too far from the school and the time I got there I saw Sidney and Tatum running into the theater building. I ran after them and when I flung the doors to the theater open they were helping Stu down from some cross. "What the fuck is going on?" I asked running down to the stage. "Fucking ghostface. I was on my back here when someone came up behind me and knocked me out," Stu said. I helped the girls cut the ropes holding him up and he fell to the stage.

"He called me while I was at the hospital. Made it sound like he had Sid," I told them. "So where is he?" Tatum asked.

"Right here."

We turned around to see him standing from the rows of seats wearing the same costume Stu and I wore. Of course he would, he was trying to be us. He was trying to finish what we had started. He walked up onto the stage slowly. "How's your sister, Billy?" He asked. He was using that stupid fucking voice box and from what I could tell he had it in the mask. "Fuck you!" I spat out. I pushed Sidney behind me, Stu doing the same with Tatum. "Where's you little helper?" I asked. "Yeah. There's no way you did it all on your own," Stu told him.

"Who are you? And why are you doing this?" Sidney asked.

He reached for the bottom of the mask and lifted it. To no surprise it was ducking Mickey. The dude had it bad for my sister. "Surprise," he said, smiling. "Not really. But what's going to be a surprise is when I fucking gut you on this stage," I told him. "Hey, I didn't want to hurt y/n. But if I can't have her then nobody can. She's alive isn't she? Maybe I'll make a visit to the hospital later."

I gripped the knife in my hand. "So where's your partner? Derek, right? That's who it is. You're obsessed with my sister. He's obsessed with my girlfriend," I said. I heard as gasp and turned around just in time to see Derek grab Sidney. "Let her go!" I yelled. "Billy." I looked into Sidney's eyes, seeing the flicker of fear. "Don't worry, baby. I'm not going to let anything happen to you."

Stu moved closer to me, "what're we gonna do, man?" He asked under his breath. Before I could answer we heard a gasp. "Stu!" Stu whipped around and went to grab ahold of Tatum but a gun was pointed at him then to the side of Tatum's head. "Not so fast. If you take one more step I'll shoot her." Stu stared at them, his fist curled into fist. "Wasn't expecting that twist were you?" Mickey laughed. I sure the fuck wasn't. But it didn't matter they would all be dead soon anyway. And I was going to save Mickey for last because he was going to get the same treatment he gave my sister. Except he wouldn't live.