I feel like something like this would happen!
Miu/Twogami as Mario (since Twogami does the fridge at the beginning and Miu almost reads "Objects that I've shoved up my arse)
Rosie and Kaede as Meggy
Kokichi/Himiko as Bob
Hifumi/Fujisaki as Boopkins (Hifumi suggests the Anime Club while Fujisaki suggests the Friendship Club)
Ryoma as Axol
Kaito and Chiaki as SMG4
Tsumugi as Tari
Gonta as Luigi
Nekomaru/Hiyoko as Shroomy
