Supernatural Imagines

8. Who do I Choose? Part 1 (Sam and Dean x Reader)

Requested by: foofighters567

Thank you for being our first request, and I hope you enjoy!

***

    You walk into the bunker, a grocery bag hanging from your arm. The impala's keys were in your other hand. Dean was craving pie, and we ran out of beer, much to Sam's distaste, so you offered to go out and pick up some more. In all honesty, you just wanted to drive the impala.

    As you were walking down the stairs, you hear arguing coming from the kitchen. You silently walk to the door, and listen.

    "I haven't loved anyone like this since Jess, Dean. We've been friends for years, and I really love her!" Sam exclaimed to Dean. You were confused. He hadn't been talking to anyone as far as you know.

    "Sammy, I haven't loved anyone like this ever. She's been there for me, and I've been there for her, I need her," Dean said, you could hear the anger in his voice. Dean hasn't been talking to anyone either.

    "Do you even know her favorite color? Where she was born? Her favorite food?" Sam asked. Wow, Sam must really like this girl.. you think.

    "Maybe I don't. But, I didn't get their (brother/sister) killed. I love you Sammy, but I really love y/n," Dean finishes as your jaw drops. Everything starts to hurt when you remember your (brother/sister)'s death. You didn't blame Sam. It was a freak accident.

    "Don't you dare blame that on me Dean. That wasn't my fault and you know! I love y/n too," Sam speaks exasperated. Your breathing gets shallow at the thought. Both Sam and Dean loved you.    You all had been friends since your (brother/sister)'s death.

    Very slowly, you push open the kitchen's swinging door, and stagger in. Dean and Sam both look at you with wide eyes.

    "You love me?" you whisper..   

____________________________________________

I know who I personally would choose, how about you? Comment it!

There will be a part two!

Love ya,

Kay