"Just Like Me" {Eyeless Jack x Reader} (sequel to "All Eyes")

#2; What is love?

-= POV; Y/N =-

"What is love?" Lazari asked me as I was brushing her hair. We're in her room, a couple weeks after the last incident. Zalgo had ordered me to take care of his daughter for as long as he was gone, so that's what I did.

"What is love?" I repeated her question, a frown forming on my face as I tried to think about it.

"Yeah!" She exclaimed cheerfully. Het enthusiasm made me smile.

I put the brush away and she turned around so she was facing me, I pulled her onto my lap and held her gently.

"Love is unexplainable. It feels wrong and right at the same time, it hurts and heals, it makes your stomach feel funny..." I said as I tickled her stomach, making her giggle and squeal. "It also makes your heart go faster, you get all hot from the inside out, you don't sleep or eat anymore, and when you're with the person you love you become all flustered. You don't know what to say or do." I explained.

She sat there for a while, just playing with a piece of my hair before she spoke up again, "Do you love someone?" She asked me.

It made me think.

I felt like I was, but not for anyone I knew or remembered.

"I don't know." I answered truthfully, "But I'll know when I meet that person." I smiled down at her, my (e/c) eyes glinstering through my mask's eyeholes.

Lazari stared up at me with those big innocent eyes of her, a small smile pulling on her lips. It was a rare sight to see.

"Why did you ask me about love?" I asked her eventually, curious what that was about.

I fidgeted with a lock of her hair before answering. "I read about it in a book, it said love is fake." Her voice was quiet.

I chuckled, "Some indeed do believe love isn't real, but that's because it has hurt them in the past really badly or they've never experienced it before. But for everyone it's different." I explained to her, giving her a gentle hug.

"I have something to show you." She told me out of nowhere, wriggling herself out of my arms and running cutely her way to one of the bookshelves. I followed behind her, watching how she pushed away some books and picked up a document. It's a dirty yellow folder with some black, red and brown bloodstains on it.

"I found it in my father's office yesterday." She told me, handing it to me.

I took it from her and sat down on the ground, my back against the bookshelf. She sat down next to me, curiously looking over my shoulder at the folder. I opened it and a couple papers fell out.

I looked at the ground and noticed they were profiles of other Creepypastas with their picture. I put them all next to each other, looking them over with a frown.

Jeff The Killer
• Full name: Jeffrey Alan Woods
• Gender: Male
• Type of pasta: Psychopathic Serial Killer
• Status: Alive
• Species: Human
• Skills: Hand-To-Hand Combat Prowess, Enhanced Senses, Athleticism, Inhuman Durability, Inhuman Stamina, Great Stealth.
• Danger level: 8

Homicidal Liu
• Full name: Liu [Unknown] Woods
• Gender: Male
• Type of pasta: Vengeful Serial Killer
• Status: Alive
• Species: Human
• Skills: Tracking, Stealth, Hand-to-Hand Combat Skills, Increased Strength, Enhanced Speed
• Danger level: 7,2

Ticci Toby
• Full name: Tobias Erin Rogers
• Gender: Male
• Type of pasta: Tragic Serial Killer
• Status: Alive
• Species: Human
• Skills: Axemanship, Physical strength, Speed, Sense focusing, Genetic pain immunity, Enhanced stamina, Elusive nature, Stealth
• Danger lever: 7,9

But there was one file that really stood out to me:

Eyeless Jack
• Full name: Jack [Unknown] Nichols
• Gender: Male
• Type of pasta: Cannibalistic Murderer
• Status: Undead, Eliminated
• Species: Demon
• Skills: Can see with presumably no eyes, Incredible stealth, Murder skills, Mutilation, Speed, Anatomical knowledge, Intelligence
• Danger level: 8,5

His picture was missing, in contrast to all the other files. But something about his name reminded me of something, just like the rest of the pastas. His Danger level was way higher than the others as well.

"This one was hidden away." Lazari told me, handing me a paper. It was written in blood:

Bunny
• Full name: (Y/N) (Y/M/N) (Y/L/N)
• Gender: Female
• Type of pasta: Cannibalistic Murderer
• Status: Alive
• Species: Human
• Skills: Enhanced senses, Intelligence, Enhanced strength, Enhanced stamina, Enhanced stealth, Combat skills
• Danger level: 8,1

I dropped it and jumped up, taking some steps back as I looked down at my hands. It even has a photo of me attached to it.

"Ms. Bunny? Are you okay?" Lazari's small worried voice echoed through my head.

I looked at her, and she looked very worried for me. I let out a shaky breath. "Let's go for a walk in the courtyard, alright?" I suggested to her, quickly picking the documents back up and hiding them before walking with Lazari out of her room.

She was skipping in front of me as we made our way to the courtyard, she was giggling and singing the whole time. She's so sweet, how could a sweet girl like her be the daughter of that demon king Zalgo?

"Ms. Bunny! The door is locked!" Lazari's voice pulled me out of my thoughts.

"Locked? Are you sure?" I asked the small girl, quickening my pace so I reached the door waster. I pulled and pushed the big doors, and it was indeed locked.

"Don't even bother, it won't budge." I heard deep and raspy voices behind me, it was a bit too familiar. ..

I froze as I recognized the voice. I slowly turned my head to see Zalgo standing behind me. "S- Sir..." I greeted him, giving him quickly a deep bow.

"You've been snooping." His voices boomed with anger.

"Yes, sir." I answered truthfully.

"You know what happens if you don't obey, so why did you do it?" He asked.

When I didn't answer he sighed in frustration. "I'll have to kill you if you don't obey!" He shouted, causing my ears to ring.

Without another warning he started approaching me, the intention that he was going to kill me is clear, and there's no escaping it.

I kept my head low, awaiting my fate for which felt like an eternity.

I'm sorry, Lazari.

I'm sorry, Jack.

-= A/N =-

CLIFFHANGER~~~

you're unbelievable.

WHAT?

you don't update for weeks and now you finally do, you decide to keep our readers on a cliffhanger?

YUP :D

you should be in jail.