"Just Like Me" {Eyeless Jack x Reader} (sequel to "All Eyes")

#3; The apple of my eye

-= POV; (Y/N) =-

Suddenly a sarcastic clapping was heard from behind us. I looked up, seeing a fermiliar masked face sitting on top of one of the open doors.

"Phenomenal!" He told us with a low chuckle.

Blue mask...

No eyes...

Black goo coming out of his eye sockets...

He looks so familiar, yet so strange...

I looked at the demon boy through the eyeholes of my bunny mask, trying to figure out who he is.

He looked straight at me. A chuckle escaped his throat. "Have you brainwashed her or something?" He asked Zalgo nonchalantly.

The demon lord himself seemed baffled by him. "You- You're not... Dead?" He asked him.

"Of course I'm not!" He laughed as he jumped down from the door, landing steadily on his feet.

"EJ!!" Lazari exclaimed happily, running up to the boy, I assume is Jack, and giving him a big hug.

"Hey there, little girl!" He chuckled, hugging her back.

Zalgo growled in anger, stomping towards me and lifting me up by my throat, making Jack freeze in place.

"You should be DEAD!!!" His voice boomed through the castle.

I started to choke, my hands up to his hand and trying to squirm my way out of his grasp. "Let. Me. Go." I hissed at Zalgo, the pain being unimaginably unbearable.

But he only tightened his grasp.

In the corner of my eye I saw Jack grabbing a... Scalpel? What does he think he can do with a surgical knife?

"Houston, we have a problem!" He yelled out, and out of nowhere three other guys appeared around us.

One was very pale, had longer stringy black hair and a cut smile through his cheeks. He had a kitchen knife.

Another had brown messy hair, was wearing goggles and a mouth guard. He had two hatchets, one looking newer than the other.

And the third one had a trench coat, a green and white striped scarf and green eyes. He had a knife as well.

What the Hell is going on here?

I opened my mouth to say something, but I got thrown away, hard against the wall falling hard onto the ground and hitting my head.

I don't know how long I was unconscious for.

Hours?

Days?

Weeks?

Months?

I wouldn't know...

Not that I wanted to know, really...

"I think she's waking up!" An unfamiliar voice called out, followed by chairs moving and footsteps walking towards me.

I'm laying in something warm, something comfy. It felt like a bed.

I groaned as I tried to open my eyes, them fluttering open only to be met by a pair of hazel eyes and a gashed cheek.

"WHAT THE FUCK?!" I yelled out, immediately punching the guy looming over me. I sat up straight in the bed, crawling backwards until I hit the cold wall, pressing my back up against it.

"W- Who are you?!" I demanded. Immediately when I barked those words I saw the guy with the smile look away, pain in his eyes. The guy with the scarf just looked at me in disbelief while Jack helped the guy I just punched.

"She really forgot..." The guy with the scarf said, his voice barely above a whisper. He was hurt.

"Of course she did, Liu! EJ already told us she was brainwashed!" The guy with the smile yelled at the guy whose name is apparently Liu.

Of course! How could I be so stupid? Now I recognized them from the pictures in those files!

"Jeff The Killer... Homicidal Liu... Ticci Toby... And-..." I summed up in a whisper, looking at each one of them as I mumbled their names. But I stopped at Jack.

"Eyeless Jack..." I whispered, memories flooding back.

They all looked at each other, surprised, confused, shocked but blessed.

"Yeah, it's me." Jack said, a smile forming on his face. Only now I had noticed he had taken his mask off, and that my mask was missing as well.

Jack approached me, climbing onto the bed next to me. When he was close enough I kicked him in the face, making him fall backwards with his head off the edge of the bed. He grabbed his mouth, he probably bit his lip or something.

"What the Hell was that for?!" He shouted angrily, sitting upright again and wiping his mouth. He indeed bit his lip.

"That was for turning into a fucking yandere!" I shouted back at him. It didn't even take a second before I grabbed his dark blue hoodie and pulled him towards me, kissing him for less than half a second, leaving him stunned. "And that was for changing." I said to him, licking his black blood off my lips.

He just stared at me in disbelief. "Wow..." He muttered. We just stared for a moment before he grabbed my neck and kissed me again, pushing me against the wall.

"Okayy!" Toby said, turning around while Jeff immediately went to shield the eyes of his younger yet taller and more mature brother.

Somehow the kiss brought back so many memories. I remembered everything.

When he pulled away I just kept staring into his empty eye sockets.

"Are you guys done yet?" I heard Toby ask.

Jack and I laughed at it. "Yeah." I answered.

I could hear a sigh of relief before Toby turned back around, followed by Jeff removing his hands from Liu's eyes.

"EJ, if you ever hurt my cousin, I'll kill you." Jeff hissed at Jack. Liu even grabbed his knife to show they weren't joking.

"Good luck with surviving these two." I giggled.

Jack laughed and sat down next to me, wrapping his arm around my waist and pulling me closer, causing me to fall into him. I laid my head on his shoulder, closing my eyes.

That was when we heard a knock on the door...

-= A/N =-

SWEET HOME ALABAMA~

you need to stop leaving the readers on cliffhangers.

YEAH, PROBABLY