The Story and Timeline of Five Nights At Freddy's (And the fanverse)

I could've saved him (1983)(AU)

Annabelle: William? What are you doing up so late?

William was doing paperwork for a moment and then he broke down

William: I could've saved him

Annabelle: Honey, please-

William: I- I was there, I ignored Evan on his birthday because I was busy working, but then when I heard that noise of the animatronic mouth shut, and the crush of Evan's head, I saw it happen and I did nothing, I watched my son die in front of me and did what?

William: NOTHING!

William: I could've stopped it- I could've- it's all my fault, I watched him die, I watched the life leave his eyes as he stared at me, silently screaming for his father to help him...

William: *crying* I neglected my own children, I feel terrible, I neglected and ignored Evan and I had to watch him die by his older brother, goddammit Michael

Annabelle: It's okay William, I still love you

William: I never wanted to hurt my own children because if I did, people might find out and I would be in trouble, but when you had Michael, I didn't want to be a father especially since I became busy running the restaurant with Henry, but when Evan and Elizabeth were born, I wanted to love them as much as possible but I didn't because of work and I neglected them and now Evan's dead and it's all my fault

Annabelle: I understand

William: I want to tell you...since I was a kid, I wasn't normal, other kids bullied me at school, and when my parents knew about some of the things I did like cutting birds open, they sent to the hospital to get treatment, they tried to spend more time with me, then in 1965, my dad killed my mother all because of some woman he met who later became my stepmother, I hated my dad and the woman he was with, she manipulated my father to kill my mother, then in 1970, three years after you had Michael, I killed my father and stepmother, butchered them, dismembered them into pieces

William: I felt sick, I never wanted to hurt my own children just like my father did but...

Annabelle hugs William as he cries

William: I'm so sorry Annie, I'm a failure, I'm a terrible husband, I'm a terrible father and I'm sorry if I've let you down

Annabelle: I love you William

William: I love you too Annie

Note: The Crying Child's name isn't actually Evan