Learning to Love You (Elizabeth Olsen x fem G!P reader)

6. How Much More?

Elizabeth POV

My eyes widen a little as I look at Scarlett whose cheeks have turned red.

"You idiots know why." She says with a roll of her eyes but the flushed cheeks have me sold and now I have questions.

"You two dated?" I ask as I let go of Robbie's hand to stand next to Scarlett.

"Yes/yeah." Scarlett and Y/N answer at the same time.

"What? When?" I ask not even knowing why I'm so curious about it. Maybe because of the fact I never knew Scarlett liked women.

"It was before I met Romain. Who Y/N actually introduced me to." Scarlett explains and now I'm the one taking her phone to get Y/Ns side.

"Why is everyone taking my phone?" I ignore her and question Y/N.

While we do this Robbie, Tom, and Jeremy are helping Evans and Hemsworth into their car.

"Well, it's what Scarlett said, really." She says with a shrug, and I frown turning to Scarlett.

"I thought you were straight," I said and she clicks her tongue.

All she does is raise her eyebrow at me as if the question I asked was stupid.

"Why'd you break up?" Again another question comes out of my mouth before I can stop it.

"We were better off as friends." Y/N explains, yawning halfway through, "And we both started to have feelings for different people, so, yeah."

"But we were friends before we dated and will continue to be friends," Scarlett states with a firm nod of her head.

"Do you still have feelings for each other?" Again what the hell, is this word vomit?

Y/N eyes widen as she hiccups and her phone is tossed up and there's a bang, "fuck!"

Scarlett snorts waiting until the camera is picked up, to look at Y/N with her signature smirk.

"Don't tell me you still have feelings for me L/N." The smugness in her voice makes me chuckle slightly.

"As if, I found a replacement for you, years ago." Scarlett's jaw drops and now Y/N is smirking.

I like the back-and-forth between these two. I guess you can love someone but they aren't right for you and still have them as a friend.

I bit my lip to stop the thought of me and Robbie being like that. But it doesn't work.

If we broke up would we be friends? Could we be friends?

Would we even break up? Could we have a relationship like Scarlett and Y/N?

"Okay, yeah, I think it is definitely time for everyone to get home," Scar said once we got to her car, where everyone was waiting since we all parked close together.

"Ah, sorry Scar, I gotta go. But it was nice to meet you, Lizzie. And Robbie, bye Chris 1 and Chris 2. Bye, Renner!"

Chris 1 and Chris 2? I let out a snort, as Jeremy smirks.

Both Chris' let out grumbles but she's already hung after the non intoxicated people said goodbye.

I give Scar her phone pulling her into a hug and thanking her for the night out. Then I moved on to Jeremy, then Evans and Hemsworth who were now debating about who was "Chris 1."

Jeremy sighed and joked about how he was gonna have to deal with their shit in the morning.

Then they got in their cars and Robbie went to ours and I walked Tom over to his out of politeness.