Supernatural Imagines

Pick Me (DeanxReader)

Write one where Sam and the reader get captured by demons, and dean has to choose which one lives and which one will die. 

Part One -Dean Pov-

"Take this damn sack off my head." I demanded when I was pushed down onto a chair.
"Dean?" I heard a familiar voice.
"(Y/n)? Sweetheart is that you?" I tried to get my hands untied from behind me. But all of a sudden the sack was pulled off of my head and sitting in front of me was (y/n) and Sam. "Sammy." I looked at my tied up little brother.
"What's going on?" Sam asked before the sack flew off his head.
"Demons." (y/n) sighed before the sack flew off her head.
"Who the hell are you?" Sam looked over at her.
"She's my girlfriend." I sighed as she looked at me.
"You have a girlfriend? Since when?" Sam looked at me.
"This honestly isn't the time to talk about this" (y/n) groaned frustrated.
"A year and a half." I told Sam and (y/n) threw her head back.
"Why didn't you tell me?" Sam asked me.
"Because I asked him not too" (y/n) lied "Now please, this isn't important. They brought us all here for a reason, they have a plan and if we don't come up with one we're all going to die." She finished
"Pushy." Sam muttered and (y/n) glared at him.
"Let's just find a way out of here." I mumbled as I looked around.
"Only two of you will get to leave." A demon appeared before us. "And you Dean Winchester get to make the choice of who lives, and who dies."
"Excuse me?" I looked up at the demonic son of a bitch.
"I don't like repeating myself Dean. You heard what I said. Take your pick. Will it be your little brother" He paused and smirked "Or your lover."
"I will skin you." (y/n) hissed as she looked up at the demon while struggling with her bindings.
"Only if you live." The demon chuckled. I looked between Sam and (Y/n).
"You can't expect me to choose." I stated
"He chooses Sam." (Y/n) stated and I stared at her wide-eyed
"What? I never said that!" I yelled as two demons appeared behind her.
"So you choose (y/n)." The demon smirked as he motioned for the two demons behind (y/n) to move behind Sam.
"I never said that!" I screamed
"Then who is it!" The demon groaned angrily
"I don't know!" I sighed
"He chooses Sam, just take me away dammit." (Y/n) groaned
"What the hell are you doing (y/n)!" I stared at her.
"Saving your brother." She sighed as the demons behind her untied her from the chair and helped her stand up.
"I can't let you do this!" I fought to stand up.
"You won't kill your brother and I know you won't kill me. So, I'll kill myself." She sighed
"Untie me! Let me say goodbye!" I looked up at the demon. He snapped his fingers and I fell out of my chair. I quickly stood up and went to (y/n). I quickly pressed my lips to hers. "I'll get you back." I told her.
"Don't. I don't want to come back if you sell your soul." She rested her forehead against mine.
"I love you." I kissed her nose.
"I love you too." She sighed before the demons placed their hands on her shoulders and the three of them disappeared. I turned around and looked at the demon who constructed this hell of a day.
"Good game boys." The demon smirked and snapped his fingers and Sam and I were left alone. I walked to Sam and untied him.
"You killed your girlfriend for me." He muttered.
"She did it to protect you." I stated as I stood up.
"Why would she do that? She doesn't even know me." Sam looked at me.
"This isn't the first time." I said as I tensed up.
"What do you mean this isn't the first time?" Sam looked at me confused
"She has saved you before. It's how we met." I explained

Part Two- Two Years Earlier, Reader Pov-

"Let me out so I can help dammit!" I growled as the man tightened the ropes around my wrists. 

"No can do. You tried to kill me, I can't trust you." The man stood up and walked in front of me.

"I'm a hunter just like you, I can help you find your brother." I insisted "I thought you were the djinn!" I explained.

"How do I know you're not lying?" He asked

"I have no idea, but if you keep talking to me, your brother will die. Now let me out!" I yelled annoyed