The New You (AOT boys x reader)

Scolding or Advice?

You found through the rest of dinner you avoided eye contact with both Erwin and your father, your face still red and burning with a blush as the three males mingled amongst each other. But soon enough Erwin and his father were gone, you quietly cleaning in the kitchen and dreading every step your dad took into the kitchen. "I think we need to have a talk." He said softly, leaning against the counter next to you with his arms crossed over his chest. "About what?" You asked quietly, your voice almost inaudible. "About what happened before dinner." Your dad pulled you from the sink by your shoulders, pulling you into a tight, warm hug. He rubbed your back gently and sighed. "I have no problem with you dating anyone (y/n), but I'd at least appreciate it if you told me before things like /that/ happen. Before I come home one day and just find you-" He paused for a moment and made a face that made you chuckle a bit. "Kissing some boy I've never even met before." He finished, running a hand through his hair. "I approve of Erwin if you want to date him I-" "No no dad it's not like that!" You quickly cut him off, shaking your head. "We were just remembering a memory from a while ago and well, I guess we both caught up in the moment. I'm not interested in Erwin dad, at least, I don't think so." Your dad chuckled and nodded a bit, ruffling your hair and kissing your forehead. "Alright sweetheart. But while we're on the subject is there anything you want to talk about?" He asked softly. You glanced at him, and you could see the hope in his eyes that you'd tell him what happened over the week in Hokkaido, what /really/ happened. You bit your lip and sighed, looking at your feet. "W-well I almost kissed Reiner on the Ferris Wheel, but Eren sort of ruined that, and then I really did kiss Marco, but it was only for a dare! A-and then I almost kissed Eren when we got lost before Armin and Mikasa found us..." You trailed off, looking at your feet guiltily as your father just pulled you into a hug. "I'm not mad. Just promise me one thing." "What...?" "If you like any of those boys, or even ones I haven't heard about yet, don't lead them on." You nodded and pulled back, kissing his cheek. "Alright dad." You smiled. "But the thing is...I don't know who I like. I mean all the guys have such nice personalities, and they're all so sweet to me.." You pouted a bit, rubbing your face. Your father sighed and held a hand to his forehead before leaning on the counter dramatically with one hand. "Why was I blessed with such a beautiful daughter?" He faked a fainting sound as you laughed. "Thanks dad. I guess I'll just have to sleep on it." You said softly as he ruffled your hair again, smiling. "Alright, night sweetheart." "Night dad."