The New You (AOT boys x reader)

Finding out

"What do you mean she likes all of us?!" Eren demanded upon hearing Mikasa tell him and the rest of the boys your feelings. It was nearly Christmas break and with the stress of presents, homework and the boys, you ended up breaking down while you were all at Armin's house and Jean and Eren broke into a fight; as usual. You'd ran off to your house which was conveniently just down the street, so with the boys, confused and guilty, Mikasa felt the need to spill to them. "Don't ask me, it hurts my brain just trying to think of why she'd like any of you in the first place." Mikasa grumbled, crossing her arms over her chest. Armin placed a hand on Eren's shoulder as the tan boy sighed. "I mean...it sort of makes sense doesn't it?" Connie asked softly as Marco nodded in agreement. "We all have our good qualities, and our flaws. Unfortunately for us (Y/n) just so happens to see all of our good qualities." All the other boys nodded, understanding. "So what do we do now?" Levi grumbled, arms over his chest as well as he flopped down into Armin's couch. "...What if we make notes?" Bertholdt suggested after a moment. "Notes?" Reiner questioned confused as the tall brunet nodded. "Yeah...we all right her a note, assuming she'll read all of them, and give her a place to meet us. Whoever she goes too is who she's decided on." The boys looked at Bertholdt, all in thought before Jean finally spoke up. "It sounds crazy but...it works." The others nodded. "Then there should be ru-" "If there's going to be any rules Mikasa, Hanji and I get to make them." Sasha said firmly, standing up from her spot on a couch from where she'd been sitting next to the spectacled girl. The boys groaned before nodding. "Fine, what're your rules?" Erwin questioned, the boys now all standing and listening intently. Sasha spoke up first. "The notes aren't allowed to be longer than a page." A couple groaned but nodded as the girls continued. "You all have to have different meeting places but have the same times so you know if (Y/n) doesn't show up, it isn't you." "You're not allowed to mention any of the other boys in your notes." "You can't give the note to her directly, all notes must be put in her locker for her to read afterschool." "We get to read them first before they're given to make sure none of you have broken the rules." Once all the rules were stated the boys all nodded, looking at each other before Connie stood in the middle and put his hand out. "May the best man win." He smiled at the others, a sort of nervous but determined look in his eyes. Jean smiled back at him and put his hand in next, followed by Levi and Erwin before the others. "Fair game boys." Hanji smirked, the girls watching as they had a group hug.