Katie McCabe x Arsenal!Reader
Where Katie loses her temper during a match and you're on the receiving end of her punch
~
Arsenal was known for its family dynamic, but even within family's there were links that didn't work as well as others. Within Arsenal that was you and Katie, you both worked great with the team, just not always with each other.
The two of you were polar opposites. Katie was outspoken, and fierce. She was often described as an aggressive player, and had a tendency to let her emotions get the best of her on the pitch. You, on the other hand, were more reserved, practical, and strategic. You kept your cool even in the tensest moments.
Your interactions with each other mostly consisted of professional exchanges, never really meeting outside of football. You of course had many team outings outside of football with the team, but either only one of you attended or you'd stay away from each other at it. The dynamic worked well enough for the team, so everyone just let it be what it was.
After Katie got taken down for the fourth time against Tottenham, it was to no surprise to you that she got up and shoved the player that fouled her. You roll your eyes as you run over to aid Kim, who was trying to get in between Katie and Ashleigh Neville. The two of them are now yelling at each other and pointing angry fingers. Poor Kim you thought, as you arrived.
Katie lifts her arm in a punching motion, and you're quick to grab ahold of her arm and pull it back, "Katie, please calm down." Katie in all her anger pulls her arm out of your hold only for her elbow to smash into your face. You stumble backwards and instantly reach for your face.
Somehow Katie immediately calms down when she realises that she hurt you. She left Asleigh Neville alone without a second thought and knelt to your side. "Shit, I'm sorry y/n. Are you alright?" You look up at her, "Just piss off, Katie." She raises her hands and steps aside. The medical team comes to check you out since you were still clutching your face.
"Is it broken?" You ask them as you remove your hand to reveal a bloody nose. The medics get to work on checking it out. Katie steps forward to get to your side, but Steph holds her back "She told you to go away, mate, give her some space." They worriedly look at your bloody face. "Since when do you care about y/n?" Beth asks when she joins the pair.
With a furrowed brow Katie turns to Beth, "What are you talking about? I've always cared." Beth snickers, "Well, maybe you should act on that, cause most people think that the two of you hate each other."
"It's not broken," You release a sigh of relief. "But your cheek has already started bruising a little, so I'm afraid you will get a black eye." You look over to Katie and roll your eyes. All of this over a stupid tackle. You let the medical team help you up, and keep a cloth to your nose as they walk you off the field.
Since there was already a bit of swelling in your cheek, they thought it was best to get you subbed off, as you hit the 60 minute mark anyways. You're still annoyed though, cause you definitely could've played the full 90 minutes if Katie had just stayed calm. You watched the rest of the match on the sidelines with an ice pack held on your face.
Beth's words lingered on Katie's mind. Did people really think you hated each other? Did you think she hated you? She was determined to take Beth's advice and show that she did actually care about you.
You were confused when you heard a knock on your door the next morning, and your confusion grew even more when you realised who was at your door. "Katie, what are you doing here?"
Katie's focus was on your face, and the black eye that had fully made its way onto your face. "If you're just going to keep staring, I'm closing the door." Your words brought Katie back to reality. "Sorry, I didn't mean to stare. I am actually here to apologise for hurting you." She holds up the small bouquet of flowers for you to take. "I know it's not much, but I wanted to check in to see how you were doing, and tell you how terribly sorry I am for letting things get out of hand, and hurting you in the process."
You're a little stunned by Katie's apologies, never having expected her to do so, and definitely not in a home visit scenario. "Thank you, Katie. I appreciate it, really." You take the flowers from her. Before you can say anything else, Katie reaches for something else. "I also got you some breakfast. Beth said you loved this place, but I didn't know what you liked from their menu, so I got a bunch of stuff. I didn't think just flowers would be enough."
The gigantic bag of food comes into your line of vision and your eyes widen. "That is food for a whole village." You step to the side and watch Katie expectantly, "Are you not coming in to help me eat this massive bag of food?"
Katie grins, maybe you didn't hate her after all. "I'd love to." She steps inside and follows you to the dinning table where she starts unpacking the various containers. You watch your table get fuller and fuller, "While I appreciate it, you know you didn't have to do all of this right?" Katie looks up at you with sincere eyes, "I wanted to. I know we tend to have our differences, but I wanted to make sure that you didn't think I hated you or something."
You shake your head instantly, "I never thought you did. We're just polar opposites in our approaches to things, and sometimes those differences don't click." Katie sighs in relief before taking a seat. "That's good to hear, and yeah we can have quite different approaches, but that doesn't mean we can't try to find a way to work better together." In agreement you nod your head. "I'd like that."
As you both start eating, the conversation flows more easily than you expected. You and Katie were usually not in a setting like this, but you had expected awkwardness or tension. Neither one was there, you felt comfortable sharing breakfast with the defender.
Halfway through breakfast you catch Katie staring at your bruise again. "You know staring at it isn't going to make it heal quicker, right?" Her face instantly turns serious. "I am really sorry about what happened yesterday. I lost my temper and you paid the price. I promise that it won't happen again." You smile appreciatively, "Apology accepted. I know you never meant to hurt me, but it did sting a little. Literally." You eye Katie on the last word of the sentence and the both of you burst out laughing.
Once you've calmed down, Katie turns to you. "Maybe you can teach me your ways of always staying calm out on the pitch?" You nod, "I can definitely do that, but only if you teach me how to stand up for myself more on the pitch. I think we could learn from each other and have more of a middle ground, what do you think?" Katie smiles and nobs, "I like that, it's a deal."
While your on pitch behaviours aren't changed instantly, the team noticed an immediate difference in your and Katie's relationship off the pitch. During training you actually worked together, and outside of football they saw the two of you in the same places for the first time in a long time.
Since that apology breakfast, Katie had come over more often. At first it was just to 'take care of you' since she was the reason you were injured, though you kept insisting that you were totally fine. Once the bruise was fully healed, Katie couldn't use the same excuse anymore, but you were also enjoying her presence so you didn't need a reason.
It surprised you at first, how much you had in common with the defender, but once you set aside your differences, you and Katie grew closer together quickly.
Then one day after practice Katie approached you. "I know we usually do breakfast, but there is this new restaurant that opened up near my place that I think you would really like. Could I take you there some time, maybe?" Your smile grows, "Are you asking me out on a date?"
Katie nervously looks up at you, "Yes, but it could be as just friends if you'd be more into that." Your smile grows even bigger, "I never imagined I'd see the day when Katie McCabe would be nervous." You chuckle lightly as a blush creeps up onto her cheeks. "I would love to go on a date with you." You place a kiss on her cheek, and then turn and walk away. "Pick me up tonight at 6pm?" Katie smiles, "I'll be there!"
