His favorite thing about you
Jeff:
Your hairBEN:
Your lipsEyeless Jack:
Your good sense of humorMasky:
Your eyesHoodie:
Your smileTicci Toby:
Your noseLaughing Jack:
Your voiceHomocidal Lui:
Your laughLost sliver:
Your personalityBloody Painter:
Your hands.Doctor Smiley:
Your listening skills
YOU ARE READING
CreepyPasta Scenarios
FanfictionCreepy-Pasta boyfriend preferences and Imagines -Requests open- Jeff the Killer BEN drowned Eyeless Jack Laughing Jack Masky Hoodie Homicidal Liu Bloody Painter Dr. Smiley Lost Silver Ticci Toby