Jeff:
Chris HemsworthBEN:
Benedict CumberbatchEyeless Jack:
Dylan o' BryanMasky:
James FrancoHoodie:
Jensen AckelsTicci Toby:
Tom HiddlestonLaughing Jack:
Leonardo DiCaprioHomocidal Lui:
Misha CollinsLost sliver:
Matt SmithBloody Painter:
Josh HutchersonDoctor Smiley:
David Tennant
YOU ARE READING
CreepyPasta Scenarios
FanfictionCreepy-Pasta boyfriend preferences and Imagines -Requests open- Jeff the Killer BEN drowned Eyeless Jack Laughing Jack Masky Hoodie Homicidal Liu Bloody Painter Dr. Smiley Lost Silver Ticci Toby