When Love Conquers Two

Chapter 9

Previously in When Love Conquers Two
The boys were furious about being pranked. Sarah hung out with Ashton and the rest of the 5SOS guys. The guys found out that Sarah can play the drums and the guitar very well. Luke found Sarah while she was changing her bandages. Sarah told the rest of Torn Silent, the boys, and the guys that she's been cutting still. Sarah finds out that Louis use to cut. Ashton and Sarah told Niall that they're dating. Niall left the arena before anyone else did.
---------------------------------------------------
It's the next day, around 10ish. Maya, Alyssa, Jake, and I are over at the boys' hotel room. We're all in the living room except for Niall. "Did Niall ever come home?" I ask the group. "I believe so. I heard the door open and giggling," Zayn says. I hear a door open and look up. I see the last person anyone would expect to see, Abby. Abby's the girl who ruined high school for me, she's the girl Alvin cheated on me with multiple times. We were friends in middle school, but she told the entire school I was Harry's little sister when I told her to keep it a secret. I stand up. "What the bloody hell are you doing here?" I demand. "I slept with Niall last night," she says. I can feel everyone's eyes on me. "You what?" Jake says. "Oh, hey baby. I didn't know you were here," Abby says. "Baby?!" I nearly scream looking at Jake. "I'm his girlfriend," Abby says. "Ex-girlfriend now," Jake says. "Let me get this straight. You just slept with Niall?" I say looking at Abby. "Yup," Abby says smiling. Niall walks in. "You son of a bitch," I say marching over to Niall. "What?" Niall asks. "You bloody know what I'm talking about. You fucking slept with Abby!" I scream at him. I can see Harry by my side in the corner of my eye. "I was drunk! I didn't know!" Niall says. I storm over to Abby and drag her into the kitchen. I let go of her. "Why? Just tell me why you want me to be miserable every day of my life?" I say. "It's fun to fuck with you," Abby says. "What did I ever do to you?! I was your best friend! Why the bloody hell did you have to go and ruin my middle school and high school experience?!" I say. She doesn't say anything. She just starts pacing. "Would you stop pacing and answer the damn questions!?" I practically yell. She stops and faces me. "I never meant for things to get so bad that we were enemies. I was jealous that you got to meet the boys of One Direction. I thought your brother was cute. I didn't know what to do to meet him. I guess I thought telling everyone that you were his sister would make me popular and get him to notice me. I didn't think it through," Abby says. "Clearly," I mumble crossing my arms. "Then explain to me why you hated me in high school and why you got Alvin to cheat on me with you," I say. "I was pissed that Alvin dumped me for you. So, I thought the best way to get back at you was to fuck him," she says. "And the other 5 times?" I ask. "When I get drunk, I sleep with Alvin and when it's not Alvin, it's Trevor. Only this time it was with Niall," Abby says. I guess by the look on my face, she can tell I'm pissed. "Sarah, I'm sorry. I never meant for you to get hurt. I'm so so so sorry," Abby says basically pleading. "I believe what you did all of that for the reasons you did it for. Exactly why would you lie to me?" I say. "None. We were honest as best friends and honest as enemies," she says. I take a deep breathe and say, "I forgive you." "You do?" she says confused. "Yea. You would never lie to me as friends or enemies. You were trouble in high school," I say. "True," she says. Neither of us say anything for a while. "Friends?" Abby says breaking the silence. "Friends," I say. We hug then exchange numbers. "How did you even meet Niall to begin with?" I ask. "We were at a bar...."

A little while later Abby finishes and we leave the kitchen. We walk into the living room to find no one there. "Sarah! Get in here!" I hear Maya scream. I look at Abby and we both bolt to the sound of the scream. I go into a room and see Niall pinned against the wall with the boys surrounding him. Jake, Maya, and Alyssa are trying to pull them off him. "Get away from him!" I scream at the top of my lungs. Everyone looks at me. "Step away from Niall, right now, or I swear to god none of you will see the light of day again," I say as cruel as possible. Everyone steps back away from Niall. Harry shoves Niall into the wall before backing away. I walk near Niall and stop a few feet away from him. I see that Niall as a black eye and there's a whole in the wall next to his head. I face the group. "Everyone get out. Now. Harry, Louis. I'll speak to you two later," I say glaring at them. As soon as everyone leaves and the doors closed, I face Niall. I step back from him. "Sarah, I was drunk. I didn't know it was her until I woke up," Niall says. "Do you remember anything from last night?" I say crossing my arms. "Not much. I remember leaving the arena, going to a bar and a girl talking to me then me coming back here," he says. "Well, Abby remembers everything from last night," I say. "What happened?" he asks. "Roselinde was there and she was flirting with you. She was practically dry humping you, apparently. Abby came over and started acting like she was your girlfriens, which scared Roselinde off. You bought Abby a drink. She got drunk while you got wasted. You two ended up taking a taxi back here," I say. "Seriously?" Niall asks. "Yea..." I say trailing off. "There's something else, isn't there?" he asks. "Abby told me that you never said her name once. She told me how you thought she was someone else," I say. "Who?" he asks. I take a deep breathe and say, "you thought it was me."