Convince Me *WWE*

Chapter Five

I woke up and saw him next to me.

I sat up rubbing my eyes as he woke up.

"Good morning." He said.

I stayed silent.

I know I shouldn't be doing this, but I've never experienced love before. I don't want the feeling to stop. He makes me feel it even though I'm just being used by him.

I got up quickly and walked out of the room, I need to stop this. But I just don't know how.

"Pam?" He asked using my real name.

"Don't call me that."

"You know that Bayley isn't your name."

I roll my eyes and walk away from him.

"What's wrong I thought we made up last night?"

I sigh frustrated, "I don't know why I even went back to you."

He smiles at me, "You love me."

He walks over to me and hugs me. My body quickly tenses up.

"Calm down." He whispers in my ear and I back up.

"I'm not going to hurt you again."

He kisses me and I close my eyes knowing that he's lying, but I believe him.

He pulls away and smiles at me and I look down.

Someone knocks on the door and I open it.

"Hey Bayley." Finn says.

"Hi."

"Can I come in?" He says.

Finn stands there and he walks over to us, "Why is he here?"

"Why are you here?" Finn crosses his arms.

"I'm apart of NXT now, coworker." He smiles and turns to me, "I need to talk to you for a second babe."

"I'll wait here." Finn smiles and he slams the door in Finn's face.

He looks at me, "Tell him to leave."

"Why?" I ask.

"Tell him to leave or I'm leaving."

He walks to the bathroom and shuts the door.

I open the door and Finn looks at me.

"Leave." I say looking down.

"Why?" He stares at me.

"Please just go."

"Bayley-"

I quickly cut him off, "Please."

"I'll see you at the arena."

Finn smiles and walks off.

I shut the door and he walks out of the bathroom.

"You told him to leave?" He asks.

I nod.

He smiles at me, "I love you."

He doesn't... but I do or I think I do...