Imagine for God_is_my_only

865 26 3
                                    

Request- A two different endings one where I end up with Sam and the other with Dean. Please make my character short and please have me not curse.
(I did this in a reader insert)

I hurried in through the bunker door, finally escaping the bitter cold. Moving my hair out of my face since it was whipped around by the wind. I shuddered and slowly pulled off my coat. The bunker was warmer than outside but not by much.
"What is with all this living in an Arctic Circle crap?"
I mumbled with pulling off my hat and gloves. I was about to yell to the boys that I was home until I heard chatter in the library. The voices of the boys' raising, obviously getting mad at each other over who knows what.

I set the food on the table and quietly walking down to the library to hear what they were arguing about now. I was right by the doorway over hearing what they were saying.
"Dean I know we agreed to not try to make a move on her, but I like her a lot."
"Sam, so do I dude! We both said we wouldn't say anything to her and we are keeping it that way."
"No, I can't. Having her around all the time since she lives here it's too hard for me not to tell her."
My eyes widened, 'holy crap they are talking about me. Why the heck would they like me though I'm about two feet shorter than both of them. I mean I know that doesn't matter but still they are like giants.'
"You know what let's call her because she isn't home yet. So let's call her and ask her to come home and then we'll both tell her we like her and then she'll pick who she wants to be with. Okay?"
Dean sighed, but soon agreed.

I noticed too late that my phone wasn't on silent so right before I turned it on silent my ringer went off.
"Dang it."
I mumbled under my breath.
The boys come around the corner both whiter than sheep. Sam asked shakily,
"You heard all that didn't you?"
"Uh yeah."
Dean spoke up and said,
"Well I hate to do this to you, but who do you choose?"
"Um well...I choose...."

Sam-

"I choose Sam. I'm so sorry Dean. I love you just not in that way."
Dean scratched the back of his neck, but said nonchalantly
"Nah it's fine Y/N"
He walked out of the room quickly, so San and I were left alone. Sam couldn't help, but smile at you. Pulling you close to him, listening to his heart beat rapidly. I stood up on my tippy toes and pecked his lips.
Sam smiled and said
"Shall we go to dinner then?"
"We shall."
I grinned while walking out of the room with him.

Dean-

"I choose Dean. Sam please don't take it personal. I love you too just not in that kind of way."
"Don't worry about it Y/N. I get it."
Sam grabbed his laptop and walked out of the room and into his bedroom. Dean's smirk started to spread on his face. He said
"Ha I knew you thought I was adorable."
"Mhm sure Winchester."
He pulled me close and kissed me sweetly on the lips.
"Now let's go celebrate with some pie."
"Dean, you and pie. It's an unhealthy obsession."
"No it's a relationship not an obsession."
"Should I be jealous?"
"No you're way better than pie."
"Good save there Winchester."
I chuckled and playfully punched his arm.

A/N

Hey sorry this took a while but I hope you liked this! I've been having a good time on my winter break and I hope everyone had a great Christmas! Love you all!
~Baylee~

Supernatural Imagines and PreferencesWhere stories live. Discover now