Chapter Eleven - She Makes Him Tick

70 0 0
                                        

A few days after Clocky and Toby asked me for advice, Toby had finally asked Natalie out on a date. Natalie gladly accepted the invitation and asked me to help her get ready.
"Where is he taking you?" I asked her as I styled her wavy brown hair.
"I'm not sure," she said, "he told me he wants it to be a surprise."
"Awe, that's cute. I imagine it'll be worth it." After I finished doing her hair, I asked how she wanted her makeup done.
"Just a simple smokey eye, nothing too bold." I happily accepted her request and did her makeup as she asked. I obviously couldn't do anything but her eyebrow on the left side of her face due to her watch, but that was okay. She still looked gorgeous.
"Have fun, love."
"Oh trust me, I will."

A few hours later, Toby and Natalie happily barged into my room. "It's official!" Natalie yelled, bursting with excitement.
"I finally got up the courage to ask Natalie out," Toby said, twitching due to how happy he was. "Thank you so much for your help, guys" Toby and Natalie hugged Jeff and I and left our room, holding hands.  

Killing Spree (Jeff the Killer x Reader)Where stories live. Discover now