A/N: I got the inspiration from a random picture from Pinterest. The reader here is attracted to both boys and girls. They can be bisexual, pansexual, or any other sexuality that is both attracted to a guy and a girl. They also don't know Nagisa for so long.
Genre: Queer!Reader
Guide: (Y/N): Your First Name (N/N): Your Nickname
(Y/N)'s POV
'Arghh.... what should I do? I can't keep this secret hidden any longer... he needs to know the truth...' I thought and took a deep breath, 'He deserves someone better... it's for the best' I thought sadly but agreed to it anyway.
After debating with my own thoughts, I heard a knock on the door.
"Coming!" I shouted and rushed downstairs; I opened the door and saw my boyfriend: Nagisa Shiota.
"(N/N)-chan!" he greeted giving me a hug and a peck on the lips. I smiled lovingly at the sweet gesture but it gradually turned into a frown.
"Is something wrong?" he asked concerned
"N-no! W-well... *sigh*.... we need to talk" I stated with traces of sadness in my words.
Yesterday
"Karma-kun! Do you wanna visit Nagisa? He might want some company being sick and all" I asked the red-head.
"Nah, you can go ahead, (N/N)-chan. I'm going to buy a couple of video games on my way home" he answered.
"Ehhh? All right..." I pouted and went to Nagisa's house.
When I got there, I heard a soft hoarse voice coughing from the inside. I knocked on the door, fixed my plastic bags filled with medicine and his favorite snacks, and made myself look presentable.
Nagisa's POV 'I can't believe this...' I thought in shame. Mom was out for a couple of weeks and I don't have any clean clothes... except the dresses she bought for me. I sighed and swallowed my pride; I hesitantly put on the dress:
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
'If anyone sees me like this... it will be the end of me!' I thought and coughed, 'This cold isn't doing me any good either...' I sighed and heard knocking on the door. I felt my blood turn cold as I thought of opening it or pretend that there's no one in the house.
I decided to open the door and saw (Y/N) holding two plastic bags,
"(N-N/N)-chan!" I stuttered embarrassed that my lover saw me dressed up like this.
"U-umm..." I stammered trying to think of something to say, "I-is Nagisa h-here?" they asked timidly; I noticed that their face was flushed red and was avoiding eye contact with me.
'T-they don't notice?' I thought, sweatdropping.
"U-umm...! H-he's out buying medicine! R-right! Medicine!" I answered.
"E-eh? I thought he was sick..." they mumbled to themselves.
"N-no! I-I'm his sister... Nagi! H-he's taking care of me at the moment..." I answered mentally facepalming.
"He never mentioned having a sister before though... oh well, you learn something new every day!" they beamed and I sighed in relief.
"Do you want to come in?" I asked and they nodded.
We spent the day talking and just hanging out. Even though I pretended to be a girl, I noticed that (Y/N) would get embarrassed and turn away from me when I get close to them.
"It was nice hanging out with you, Nagi-chan~" (Y/N) said by the door.
"Yeah, it was nice hanging out with you too, (Y/N)-chan" I smiled making them blush and shyly smile back.
"But I wonder when your brother comes back... it's been an hour already..." they mumbled catching me off guard.
"I-I'm pretty sure he'll come back any second now, you should go home though. It's pretty late already" I said.
"Yeah, I guess so. I hope nothing bad happens to him..." they mumbled softly with their face full of worry. I smiled at this and unconsciously kissed them,
"Don't worry, I'm sure he won't do something reckless if it means making you worry like that" I sweetly smiled and shut the door.
'W-W-WHY DID I DO THAT?!?!' I thought. blushing.
(Y/N)'s POV
"Don't worry, I'm sure he won't do something reckless if it means making you worry like that" Nagi sweetly smiled and shut the door, leaving me dumbfounded.
'Eh...' I thought still processing, '......EEEEHHHHHH?!?!?!?' I thought and started to freak out.
Ever since that accident, I couldn't look at Nagisa the same way. I felt really guilty... I kissed his sister for Pete's sake! During lunch, I decided to tell Nagisa what happened yesterday and to meet me at my house later. After school, I rushed to my house not wanting to talk to Nagisa. I fixed myself and mentally prepared myself for what's gonna happen next.
Now
"W-what did you want to talk about, (N/N)-chan?" he asked as nervous as me.
"Y-yesterday... I wanted to see you after school but instead, I met your sister" I started. I took a deep breath and averted my eyes to my hands, "A-and after that encounter... w-when I was about to go home... s-she...kissed me..." I mumbled loud enough for him to hear.
After a while, I did not a reply.
"I know what I did was unforgivable, but I had no idea that she was gonna do that! I'm really sorry, Nagisa! I-I'm really sorry! I-I couldn't even look at you in the eye at school... I--" I was cut off by a pair of lips over mine. It was the same as the kiss from yesterday but more passionate.
When he pulled away, our faces were fully pink and we were breathing heavily.
"L-listen, (N/N)-chan..." he said resting his head on my shoulder, "I don't have a sister..." he confessed surprising me.
"E-eh? But the girl from yesterday..." I said,
"That was me... I didn't have any clean clothes except for the dresses my mother would buy me... I didn't have the courage to tell you that it was actually me b-because I thought you would think of me less of a man..." he admitted. I felt his arms snake around and gave me a light squeeze, "Sorry that I made you feel like that... I-I didn't think that it would affect you that much... a-and about that kiss from yesterday... I-I just couldn't help myself... you looked so adorable and I wanted to reassure you that I was fine..." he apologized.
I wrapped my arms around his neck and pecked him on the lips.
"Idiot... your clothes don't define your gender or who you are... only you can say what and who you really are..." I mumbled burying my face into his neck.
"S-so, y-you're not weirded out?" he asked and I shook my head.
"I'm just glad I didn't do you wrong..." I mumbled in relief, "And don't worry, I won't tell Karma nor Rio" I teased.
"Pfft hehe, thank you, (N/N)-chan... I really don't know what I'll do without you"
