A/N: The boys thoughts will be in bold but the rest is just normal.
Ticci Toby
You and Toby were lying in the grass in a clearing in the woods in silence except from Toby's occasional twitching but it wasn't an awkward silence... Just peaceful which was quite rare around Toby.
Why cant I stop thinking about her? Its all I've done since I first saw her... but she couldn't love me could she? I'm a killer... SCREW IT!!!
Toby suddenly sat up and grabbed onto your arms.
"Y/N I LOVE YOU BE MY GIRLFRIEND" He screamed. You were a little taken back by his sudden outburst but your face lit up when you processed his words.
"Yes Toby!" You screamed hugging him. He chuckled and hugged you back.
Jeff the Killer
WHY CANT I CONTROL MYSELF?! I love her so much but what if I hurt her? NO! I could never hurt her... Not even if I wanted too... Believe me I tried when I first met her... I guess this is something that just has to be done...
You were sitting in your room home alone one day when you heard a noise from down stairs. You slowly crept down to see Jeff standing at the bottom with a box of chocolates and flowers. You could see that Jeff and the flowers were both covered in blood but you had gotten used to seeing it.
"Y/N I'm shit at this sort of stuff so will you go out with me?" He asked nonchalantly. You smiled and ran down beside him.
"Yes" You smiled and hugged him.
BEN Drowned
I love Y/N I do but I cant help feeling like she doesn't like me back so this is the easiest way to ask her... because if she does reject me... I wont have to deal with all the embarrassment and shit....
You and BEN played video games everyday and one day when he didn't show up on time it started to worry you but you just sighed and started without him. About half way through the game you were playing a box popped on the screen.
WILL YOU BE MINE?
YES NO
You smiled and pressed yes only for BEN to pop out of the screen and kissed you.
Eyeless Jack
You hadn't seen E.J for a few days and you were beginning to wonder if he had grown tired of you. One night when you were in your bed almost asleep.
I wish I could have just told Y/N normally but nooo. I had to go and wimp out so now here I am sitting in her room drunk, in the dark with her thinking that I hate her and waiting for her to notice me... What could go wrong...
there was a loud thud from the corner of your room. You sat up and saw E.J.
"Y/N BE MINE" He shouted slurring every word. You looked at him as you took in the smell of vodka and whisky. He was drunk. Just then he passed out on the floor. In the morning once he had sobered up you asked him if he ment what he said and he admitted it. You hugged him and said yes.
Slenderman
You and Slender were hanging out in the woods one day.
"Slender im bored" You groaned.
"Me to Y/N" He sighed. "Lets play a game" He said with a smirk in his voice. "You have to find all my notes" He said before disappearing.
I decided to come up with a little game for Y/N to play... It might be a little more fun!
