When You Ask Him if He's Gay

2K 31 17
                                    

Ticci Toby

"HOW DARE YOU Y/N! YOU KNOW I LOVE YOU AND BOOBS BOOBS ARE NICE AND SO ARE YOU AND..."

Toby began to rant about how much he loves you... and boobs...

Jeff the Killer

"You already know that i'm bi" Jeff said bluntly.

"I know but who do you like better?" You asked.

"You fucking idiot" He said pulling you into his lap and forcing his tongue  into your mouth.

BEN Drowned

"Yes" He answered immediately.

"What? ARE YOU FU...." He cut you off by kissing you.

"No but you believed me didn't you?" He smirked.

 Eyeless Jack

"I... I don't know?" he answered  confused.

"What do you mean you don't know?" You were now also confused.

"I don't know? I love you anyway" He answered again.

So yeah... He doesn't know...

Laughing Jack

"No"

"Are you straight?"

"No"

"So... what are you then?"

"Baby. I. AM. FABULOUS!" He answered before strutting out of the room.

 Masky

"Nope" He said before pinning you to the wall and making out with you.

 Hoodie

He began to stutter and blush like crazy and you felt really bad.

"I take it back i don't even know why i asked" You said cuddling into his neck.

Bloody Painter 

He just stared at you for a good 5 minutes before;

"Lets just forget that shall we?"

Creepypasta Boyfriend ScenariosWhere stories live. Discover now