Special shout out to @leopardsclaw33 for being amazing! Happy Birthday ILYSM
"Okay, now shut up," Jonah shushed his bandmates. They weren't supposed to be there. "We're gonna get caught if you don't shut up."
"Salty AF," Jack scoffed. "You're being ridiculous! We're not gonna get caught!" Jonah groaned, rolling his eyes.
"Okay, I think I hear her," Daniel pressed his ear to the bedroom door. Zach shuffled over to him.
"Is she really here?" he questioned, grabbing the knob. Corbyn yanked him back.
"Are you nuts? We can't open the door, we'll blow the secret dummy head!" he hissed. Zach pouted, scooting back to his original position. Daniel rolled his eyes and pressed his ear to the wood again. You were definitely in your apartment. He listened to you talk on the phone with your brother assumably.
"No, I was planning on quitting, I just didn't think I'd leave so quickly, I'm alright, promise. I'm just gonna shut myself in for a few days. Swear I won't bottle it up, I didn't like that place much anyway. I can get another record deal with someone else, okay? Kay, bye, love you," you said. You sighed heavily. Your footsteps grew louder as you approached your bedroom.
"SURPRISE!" the five boys screamed, putting their perfect vocals to use. You yelped and jumped back, nearly tripping over your own feet.
"What the actual fuck!?" you placed your hand over your heart. "W-What are you doing here? You five live across the country, what're you doing here?" you questioned after you calmed down enough. Jonah stepped over to you, pressing his forehead to yours, letting his eyes flutter close.
"I missed you," he breathed. "I missed you and I had to be here for your birthday."
"Aw, I'm touched. You all came out here for my birthday?" tears welled in your eyes. Jonah noticed immediately.
"Why are you crying? Are you mad? Are you hurt? Did I do something?" he asked worriedly. He grimaced. "Did someone hurt you?"
"No, no, not really. I... lost the record deal. I'm fine. The timing sucks though, why on my birthday," you wiped your eyes.
"Well, that sucks," Zach piped up unhelpfully. Jack placed his hand on his shoulder, shaking his head with a slight smirk.
"Anyway, we came because we care. And Jonah would not shut up about you, not that that's a bad thing. so we came here for your birthday, since your family's always really busy and stuff. Happy birthday!" Corbyn grinned.
"Thanks. I mean it. I... I was expecting to get a date with Netflix, but this is way better."
"So, where does the birthday girl wanna go?" Daniel asked.
After dinner, which Jonah covered, much to your slight annoyance, he dropped the boys off at your apartment, making them promise not to clear out your fridge. He started driving, not giving you any hints as to where the two of you were headed. "Oh god, am I getting kidnapped?" you joked.
"Please, if I were to kidnap you, I'd give you a puppy as bribery and put you on a plane to LA," Jonah responded.
"Wow, why haven't you kidnapped me yet?" you laughed. Jonah faltered.
"Your brother scares me," he admitted, blushing lightly. You laughed.
"Really? My big brother scares you? Holy crap!" you found it hilarious. Jonah had two to three inches on your brother and your brother tolerated Jonah because no big brother was supposed to like their little sister's boyfriends.
"He's lowkey terrifying," Jonah shrugged.
"He's weird, that's what he is," you snorted. You stared out the window, noticing where you were. "Why are we at Woodfields?"
"Can't take my girl on a date?" Jonah smirked. "Woodfields closes at nine, it's six-thirty, we got some time to shop. Eat some Auntie Anne's, grab some cinnabon, shop, makeout, just kidding no one needs to see that." You smiled at him.
"I never know what to expect from you," you chuckled, lacing your fingers with his. The words slipped past your lips before you realized your mistake.
"CAUSE ONLY NEVER COMES WHEN NEVER'S ALL YOU KNOW. YOU GOTTA TAKE THE CHANCE RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU! YOU GOTTA MAKE YOUR PLANS WHATCHA GONNA DO?! CAUSE ONLY NEVER COMES WHEN NEVER'S ALL YOU KNOW!"
"Hush Jonah, I love your singing, but Cinnabon takes precedence."
*again, happy birthday @Leopardsclaw33 you're amazing, don't forget it.*
![](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/120816690-288-k777239.jpg)
YOU ARE READING
Why Don't We Preferences
Fanfic*May contain bad words* Imagines and Preferences for Why Don't We. Feel free to comment and feed back is appreciated. Trying to post at least once a week ;)