-1 month later-
BEN DROWNED
You were watching Love, Simon at two in the morning, tears pouring down your cheeks as you did so.
"This movie has me fucked up." You mumbled as you buried your face in the couch pillow and sobbed.
Once the movie ended you felt a tap on your shoulder and looked over.
"You alright?" Ben asked worriedly.
You smiled and wiped your eyes.
"Yeah I'm good, this movie just gave me the feels." You replied as you looked at him.
He sat down next to you and hugged you.
You felt your cheeks grow warm at his embrace.
You smiled and hugged him back, wrapping your arms around him.
Ben blushed and grinned, holding you in a gentle but tighter embrace.
His heart raced fast and he pulled away, realizing what he was doing.
You rubbed your eyes and smiled again, looking back up at him.
"Thanks. I feel better now." You said with a soft chuckle.
Ben smiled and sat back close to you, then carefully moved his arm around you.
"What other movies you got?"DOLL MAKER
You sat on your couch, wanting to cry because you had a really bad headache.
You gripped the couch, wanting to rip it to shreds.
"Y/N, I'm back." Doll's voice filled the room and the sound of the front door shut.
You whimpered and closed your eyes, you wanted to sleep but couldn't.
"Here, take an Advil."
You opened your eyes and saw Doll Maker kneel down, holding a glass of water and a pill.
You sat up and he gave you the pill, you put it in your mouth and took a drink of water.
"Thanks." You said groggily as you fell back down.
Doll set the glass down on the side table and walked away.
He came back to the living room with a fuzzy blanket and a fuzzy pillow.
"Here, sit up Y/N." He said.
You sat up and he placed the pillow down.
You laid back down and felt yourself sink in the soft pillow.
You smiled, your headache feeling a little bit better.
Doll placed the blanket on you and tucked you in.
"Thank you...Doll." You mumbled as you dozed off.
Doll smiled and moved some of your hair out of your face, staring at your sleeping face.
His heart raced fast and he stood up, realizing he now has feelings for you.EYELESS JACK
You had sneaken out to go to your friends party, and now you were returning home, you opened your window and quietly crawled through it, then shutting it carefully.
You smiled and took off your jacket and looked towards your bed.
You turned on your light and saw someone was in your bed, asleep.
You rolled your eyes and put your hands on your hips. "Jack! Get outta my bed!" You shouted quietly as you walked over to his side.
He groaned and pulled the covers over him and turned away, you grinned evilly and jumped on him causing him to yelp.
"What the hell dude." He mumbled as he sat up looking at you groggily.
You let out a mischievous chuckle as you looked into his tired, and eyeless sockets.
"I'm not leaving your bed. I like it." He said as he laid back down.
You sighed, and kicked off your shoes. "Well then scoot over, I'm tired too." You replied as you laid down next to him and got underneath the blankets. Jack's cheeks turned a light pink and he felt his stomach flip as you laid down next to him.
You turned off the lights and faced him. "Goodnight Jack." You said as you closed your eyes.
A minute went by and Jack was now awake, staring at your sleeping face.
He felt his stomach flip again as he moved himself closer to you.
Jack inhaled sharply and wrapped his arm around your waist and pulled you closer.
You felt this and you blushed.
Jack closed his eyes, unaware you were listening to his racing heartbeat.HOMICIDAL LIU/SULLY
"Get outta my sight you little shit!" Your father screamed at you as he chucked an empty beer bottle. You yelped as you heard it shatter on the wall as you continued running to your room. You got in your room and slammed and locked the door, panting heavily. You heard your dad grumble and walk away. "Y/N. Are you okay?" You tuned around and saw Liu, standing by your open bedroom window. You looked down and felt tears forming in your eyes as you shook your head. He frowned and walked over to you with open arms. You ran into them and started sobbing, your hands shaking as you wrapped them around him. "There, there Y/N. Sully and I won't let him get you." Liu said as he held you gently. You squeezed him tighter as you continued crying, not wanting to let go of his safe embrace. 'Liu, I think I like Y/N...I have this feeling like I want to just...protect her.' Sully said to Liu in the back of their minds. Liu mentally nodded, 'I feel the same way.' Y/N stopped crying and looked up at Liu, a soft grin on her lips. "Thank you Liu, and Sully." She said faintly as she let go. Both both mentally frowned, wanting her back in their arms.
YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios.
FanfictionYou're the girlfriend of a notorious Creepypasta killer, what have you gotten yourself into? ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Characters: Ben Drowned Doll Maker Eyeless Jack Homicidal Liu/Sully Hoodie Jason the Toymaker Jeff the Killer Laughing Jack Mask...