Falling in Love with my Bully ✔️ #Endbullying (Completed)

Familiar Face

Monty 

I can't believe Cora does not remember Theo, has it really been that long? I guess so, anyway Theo was our best friend in kindergarten up to tenth grade, when he moved I guess everyone forgot about him except for me. He was a dick not going to lie, he literally stole Cora away from me. I should have told Cora sooner but since we were all really close I did not want to hurt anyone, but the asshole being himself did anyway. From then on I vowed to torture him by torturing Cora which seems like a dick move, but it worked. 

Theo is not a good guy, it may seem like I am the bad guy but honestly its him. The guy freaking moved to California to escape my ruthless bullying to Cora for what he did. Nina wasn't very happy about it, but at least she knows why. I told her to not tell Cora about anything until she remembers, but for being a straight A student, she has horrible memory. 

I sighed as I walked into the cafeteria only to be confronted by someone I truly hate. 

Theo. 

"Montgomery Jensen," Theo said turning around.

"Theo Contos," I said facing him. 

Cora is watching us from the other side of the cafeteria with Nina and Nina is looking at me. Fuck. 

"What brings you back to New York?" I asked coldly. 

"Why do you care?" He fired back.

"Whatever, I don't have time for this." I said pushing past him.

"Oh, you will." He replied as I kept walking out. 

Fucking asshole, Cora came up to me leaving Nina behind.

"You okay?" She asked.

"Yep." I said. 

"Who was that?" She asked.

"No one important." I said. 

I kept walking so she wouldn't keep up with me. Really why would she ask me who that was? She knows she knew him, why won't she admit it? 

Cora 

Fuck 

Is that Theo Contos? I remember that guy from a long time ago, I don't know why he is back but I remember he and Monty got in a huge fight before he left for California. 

"Who was that guy?" I asked Monty.

"No one important," He said walking away from me. 

"Whats his deal?" I asked Nina sitting back in my seat. 

"You really don't remember?" She asked.

"REMEMBER WHAT?" I whisper yelled.

"I can't tell you, its not my place." She said.

"Nina Jensen, you better tell me right now!" I demanded.

"Another time, Cora." She said eating her lunch. 

Fucking hell, why wont anyone tell me what happened? 

Theo 

You should have seen the look on Monty's face when he saw I was back. Did the asshole think he would get rid of me that easily? He thought I left because I couldnt handle what he was doing to Cora but really, I only dated her so he would leave, but obviously that didn't work out so I was the one who left. I really do love Cora but not in that way. Nina was the one I loved, but I needed a reason to leave. 

Monty gave me that reason, I told Nina when I came back that she would be all mine. 

To be honest, I don't really care for either Monty or Cora, I'm just here for the show. 

Cora was staring at us arguing earlier, Nina kept looking at me telling me to back off Monty. It was whatever, I walk up to them after Monty left.

"Hello," I said. 

"Hi." Nina said. 

"Theo?" Cora whispered.

"Its me," I said. 

"Why are you back?" She asked.

"Unfinished business," I said honestly. 

The last time we saw each other is when I disappeared back in sophomore year. I didn't tell anyone where I went and I disconnected all my social medias. 

"I am so sorry for leaving, but my family was in crisis in California, but now I'm back." I said. 

Cora didn't seem too happy about my return, but Nina gave a small smile. That adorable smile. God who wouldn't love it? While I was dating Cora, I was secretly in love with Nina. Monty found out and he said he would use it to hurt Cora and she would forever hate me unless I moved away. 

"It was good seeing you guys," I said. 

"You too Theo," Cora said. 

Any thoughts on Theo Contos coming back? 

Updated on 11/3/2019

Revision of this story is taking place, if there are any mistakes I am going back to edit those. Thank you all for reading and hopefully daylight savings didn't mess you guys up like it did for me.