My Monster Family (Eyeless Jack x Reader)

My Neighbour Ticci Toby

(A/N whew, I finished it! Sorry it took me so long but I hope you like this chapter!)

Your point of view

I happily followed Toby as he lead me to his room so we could plan our little devilish afternoon and pick a victim for our little game. We used to love playing tricks on people in our neighbourhood when we were kids. Our favourite target was Lyra, Toby's older sister. I wonder which one of the murdered we will pick on today? I bet this isn't the first time Toby plays pranks on them...I wonder who's his favourite target now.

We arrived at a brown door and Toby opened it to reveal his room. It looked a lot like Eyeless Jack's, it had a green and brown king sized bed, a desk, a bedside table, a shelf and a wardrobe in it. It was also relatively clean except for a few pieces of paper with scribbled notes on, Toby always had a rather untidy handwriting due to his constant ticks. He sat on his huge bed and patted the spot next to him, motioning for me to sit down and I did, the bed sinking in around me. He picked up a hat from his desk and gave it to me. I in return gave him a questioning look.

"It's to cho-ose who we-e're going to pra-ank. There a-are names insi-ide, pick o-one at rando-om."

I did so and took out a piece of paper from the hat and unfolded it. There was a name on it...............Slender.

Toby and I stared at each other, then at the note and then back at each other. Toby snatched the piece of paper and threw it away.

"We-e're not doing tha-at, I'd ra-ather you didn't di-ie straight awa-ay, on your fi-irst day here."

I giggled and picked another name from the hat. Drum roll please

...

...

...

The Bloody Painter!

I have no idea who that guy is but by the sounds of his nickname, he doesn't seem to me like he'll react well to our little joke. I shivered at the thought of a murderer's rage as Toby smirked at me and jumped off the bed, grabbing my hand and pulling me along with him as he rushed to his desk.

He looked down at different plans for great pranks and pointed at one. I had a little trouble reading it but when I did, a huge smile illuminated my face. This is going to be one heck of a fun day.

~~~Time skip~~~
Helen's (Bloody Painter) point of view

I had heard about the news of (Y/N)'s arrival here, information spreads like wildfire in this mansion, surprisingly enough. I also knew a lot more about her past than I probably should have, I stalked her on slender's orders more than once. She was a really nice girl, a bit shy at first due to the way she was treated by others but then she was really kind when you got to know her, which of coarse wasn't my case. I had never actually talked to the girl, or even made eye contact yet I knew her better than even E.J did due to my close analysis of her behaviour. If one person knew her better than I did though, that would have to be Toby.

I had heard that they were childhood friends and had met because of their abusive fathers' friendship. The two had immediately bonded together due to their very similarly tragic upbringing. I could tell they would have been a nice couple but they never thought about each other in that way, maybe because they were separated by Toby's "awakening", as we creepypastas call it, too early to have truly developed any feelings towards one another. Afterwards Toby met Clockwork so that chance was immediately ruined and anyway I have my suspicions that (Y/N) has feelings for Jack, which is a shame because he is probably more interested in her kidneys than anything else. I mean, the girl is human after all so we have to be careful.