Red Dead Redemption II Preferences and Oneshots 2

You walk in on Them Touching Themselves

You hear them say your name and you walking on them touching themselves (and you aren't in a relationship)

WARNINGS: NSFW/smut

Arthur-

A part of Arthur thought that what he was doing was wrong. He didn't know how he could think about you while touching himself and then talk to you tomorrow like he didn't think those thoughts about you. But he soon convinced himself that this was completely fine, it's not like you were going to find out. You heard Arthur say your name as you were walking past his tent so you assumed that he wanted to talk to you and you stepped into his tent. You couldn't help but gasp out of pure surprise when you saw the sight in front of you. Arthur's face was bright red as he covered himself up. He knew that there was no point lying about what he was doing, you had heard him and saw him. You weren't stupid, you knew perfectly well what he was doing. All he could so was apologise so that's what he would do, even if he was finding hard to even look at you without wanting the ground to open up and swallow him whole.

If you offer to lend a hand (pun totally intended), he is going to ask you to repeat yourself and ask if you're joking. He is going to assume that you're messing with him so you'd have to assure him that you really do mean it and that you would be happy to help him out. Arthur wouldn't know what to say, he didn't want you to feel like you had to help him and he didn't want you to be uncomfortable at all. Still, he couldn't turn you down. Even after that night and the pair of you have started a relationship, don't mention that encounter because it will immediately get him flustered and embarrassed.

Dutch-

Dutch hadn't started this endeavour with the intention of imagining you. As usually, you came to the forefront of his fantasies and he ended up thinking about you anyway. You heard Dutch say your name as you were walking past his tent so you assumed that he wanted to talk to you and you stepped into his tent. You couldn't help but gasp out of pure surprise when you saw the sight in front of you. Dutch would quickly cover himself up and would try to smoothly explain himself to you. He didn't want to make you feel uncomfortable but he also didn't want you to leave before he had apologised and attempted to explain himself. You had heard him say your name, he didn't know how he could explain that.

If you offer to help him, Dutch is going to go silent but only for about a second. Once he processes what you were offering, a smile would appear on his face. He would make sure to take care of you first but he was definitely going to accept your offer.

Micah-

Micah didn't see any shame in what he was doing. He didn't think it was particularly creepy for him to be thinking of you while he did this. However, he didn't mean to say your name out loud. He definitely didn't mean for you to hear him. You had heard Micah say your name so you assumed that he wanted to talk to you, so you stepped into his tent. You couldn't help but gasp out of pure surprise when you saw the sight in front of you. Micah would curse to himself and cover himself up. Micah doesn't really get embarrassed about things and he isn't embarrassed about what you saw, he didn't know how to react to the fact that you knew that he was thinking about you. Micah found it hard enough to address his feelings for you, this was the last thing he needed. He might even scold you to get out, asking you what the hell you wanted, pretending like you hadn't heard him.

If you offer to help him, he would be a little taken back. He isn't used to being in a vulnerable position and he hadn't expected you to offer that at all. However, it wouldn't take too long for a smirk to appear on his face. Any sort of shyness or embarrassment you thought that you saw on him? That's all gone now. You want him too? Then why are you still dressed? If you think that you are going to have any control here, since you caught him in a compromising situation, you're wrong. He isn't ashamed and this evening turned out much better than planned.