Amy's POV
________________________
I held her waist and pulled her onto me.
Reagan:"Wait, why all of sudden?"
Amy:"Uhm, well I, well after we kissed I knew I felt something"
Reagan:"Did you guys just break up like that?"
Amy:"Sort of, she wants to be friends again but I don't know yet"
She put her hand on my cheek.
Reagan:"If you guys really love each other you can be friends, just talk to her about it"
She kissed me softly and pulled back again.
Reagan:"Amy, you two are or were best friends and deep down you still are"
Amy:"I know but-"
I was cut off by Reagan's phone that went off. She picked up.
Reagan:"Hi"
Karma:"Reagan hi"
And surprisingly it was Karma.
Reagan:"Karma, hi, how are you?"
Karma:"I am fine, well no I'm not but is Amy with you?"
Reagan:"Uhm yeah actually she is"
It was silent on the other side for a while.
Reagan:"Karma?"
Karma:"Sorry my mom, she came in but, don't hurt her please, she is hurt enough"
Reagan looked at me. I could hear Karma's voice all the time but she didn't know that.
Reagan:"I won't don't worry"
She grabbed my hand.
Karma:"Is she there, does she want to talk?"
Reagan:"I'll give her"
She handed me the phone.
Amy:"Karma"
Karma:"Amy, I am sorry"
Amy:"Are you still sure, do you really want this?"
Karma:"If you love something set it free, it's time to let you be happy Amy"
I could feel she was crying.
Amy:"I love you too Karma"
Karma:"We'll talk later, you go back to Reagan"
Amy:"Okay, bye"
I didn't notice I was crying. Reagan grabbed my hand.
Reagan:"That was really brave of you"
Amy:"You think so? I just feel like crap"
Reagan:"Go talk to her then"
Amy:"But I don't want to leave you"
Reagan:"I will be waiting for you to come home okay?"
She kissed my cheek and I left. I was on my way to Karma's house. I knocked on her door. She opened up.
Karma:"Amy? What are you doing here?"
Amy:"I don't, I don't uhm"
Karma:"Amy what's wrong?"
Amy:"Karma I don't want to lose you"
She grabbed my hands.
Karma:"You could never lose me"
She looked in my eyes. She came closer but I held back.
Karma:"I'm sorry, I have to get used to it"
Amy:"Uhm yeah me too, but-"
Karma:"Amy I am fine with this, you can go out with Reagan"
Amy:"That's the thing, I-I miss you Karma"
She looked up to me.
Karma:"Amy I thought you were in-"
Amy:"No, I was confused but, I am still confused because we spend the night and-"
Karma:"You what?"
Amy:"We spend the night, but what I was saying is that I still have feelings for you"
She kept silent.
Amy:"Karma say something"
Karma:"I don't know Amy"
Amy:"But don't you feel something?"
Karma:"I-I do"
I grabbed her hands but she pulled back.
Karma:"No don't"
Amy:"Why?"
Karma:"Cause you chose her"
Amy:"Karm-"
Karma:"No I am not here to be you number two Amy"
Amy:"You were never my number two"
Karma:"You had to think about that before you slept with her"
Amy:"Karma that was no-"
Karma:"No Amy! It was something! It was something that hurt me!"
Amy:"Karma please don't say that I never wanted to hu-"
Karma:"But you did"
I looked at her, no words leaving my lips.
Karma:"Go please"
Amy:"Karma no I am not lea-"
Karma:"Amy, leave"
Amy:"But I-"
Karma:"Leave, now"
She looked at me angrily.
Amy:"Can I at least explain?"
Karma:"No, go explain it to Reagan, cause I don't want to hear it"
I walked out the door but I stopped.
Amy:"You are still my everything"
She looked at me but the closed the door. With the sound of the shutting door my heart fell apart.
YOU ARE READING
Soulmates
RandomThis story is about Karmy, a couple from Faking It. This is an MTV show about two bestfriends who fake being a lesbian couple. While Karma tries to get Liam's attention, Amy tries to win over Karma's love. In my version of the story Karmy is a coup...