Unsteady [Isaac Lahey x OC]

Chapter 8

"Okay, so this kid is the real murderer." Carter and Stiles' dad asked confused towards the three.

They nod their heads, looking at the yearbook picture of Matt.

"No" The sheriff simply stated.

"Yes" the twins had said in unison.

"No" Their dad rolled his eyes, "Give me a motive. Why would this kid want to kill most of the members of the 2006 swim team and their coach?"

"Isn't it obvious! Our swim team sucks, we haven't won in like 6 years!" Stiles realizes how crazy he sounds, "Okay we don't have a motif yet." He grumbles.

"Seriously Stiles" Carter rolled her eyes, "Dad you need to trust us. We know it's Matt."

He looks between the three, taking note on all of their worried faces.

"Scott do you believe these two?" He asked referring to his son and daughter.

Once Scott convinced their Dad that he should trust them, the four had headed down to the station. Convincing the sheriff that Matt was the culprit was going to be a challenge. They needed to come up with any piece of evidence they could find.

Reviewing the footage from the hospital, they stop on a clip of Matt talking to a nurse, who just happened to be one they all knew.

"He's talking to my mom." Scott says worriedly.

Matt was tracking mud throughout the hall of the hospital, which was why Scott's mom pulled him aside at the hospital and could recall who he was to Scott on the phone.

Stiles walked away, assuming he heard something Carter followed him seeing what he was up to.

"Hello?" He called out.

"Holy shit, Stiles." Carter held her hand up to her mouth as she saw the deputy who let them in was bloody lying dead on the ground. Stiles grabs his sisters hand causing her to turn around to meet were he was looking.

Matt held a gun to their heads with tears brimming his eyes. Stiles puts his arm protectively in front of Carter, even though she was the one with powers.

He leads the two into their dad's office, pushing them through the door. Scott and their dad hold their breaths seeing Stiles and Carter with a gun pointed towards them.

"Matt, you don't want to do this-" Sheriff Stilinski said calmly.

Carter reached her hand up, hoping Matt wouldn't notice but he did. He suddenly smashed the butt of the gun into Carters jaw.

Her brother, father and best friend cringed at the sight wanted to immediately run to her aid, but Matt just held the gun up.

Carter reached her hand up, blood dripping from her cheek and lip.

Matt led Stiles, Scott and Carter into the main room of the station. Supernatural things, sure Carter can handle that. Psychotic, murderous teenagers? Why did that scare her more?

Sitting with a gun still pointed towards the three, Matt wanted them to shred and delete any evidence that made him linked to the murders.

"Open it" Matt said referencing the door, knowing Ms. McCall was arriving.

"Please" Scott replied not wanting his mother involved.

"Open the door" Matt sternly said.

Derek was on the other side, thankfully not Scott's mom.

"Oh thank god." Scott said.

Carter had a glimpse of hope until Derek collapsed in front of them, the kanima behind him with his claws out.