I Hated You Now I love You

Chapter 19

*Stan’s Pov* 
It’s been a few week since Y/n and Kyle broke up. I was okay (not really) with it. Y/n loved Kyle so much and was going through hell for him then Kyle broke his heart. On top of that he got back together with Cartman! Now don’t get me wrong I love Kyle he’s my best friend, but god I don’t approve of his decisions sometimes. I also noticed Y/n went mute again...he never talked. Not even when spoken to by others. I often caught him starring at Kyle and Cartman. Poor dude... I’m going to get to the bottom of this. 
“Stan!” 
I jump and look at who had called my name. 
“Your in thinking town again, care to share?” Kenny asks as we were walking in the parking lot and to my car. 
“I want to get to the bottom of what happened between Kyle and Y/n,” I say. 
“Oh thank god I’m not the only one,” Kenny sighs in relief as we hop into my car. 
“You want to get food then stop by his house?” I ask.
“Why food first?” Kenny asks.
“Peace offering. We’ll get him a shake or something,” I shrug. 
“Yeah that sounds good,” Kenny agrees.
“Plus didn’t you need to get Butters food? He’s busy help put together the talent show,” I say.
“Yeah he is,” Kenny nods as I pull out. Kyle and Cartman ditches us and started walking home together. 
-After grabbing food- 
I pulled into Y/n’s drive way. We both got out and walked to the door. I knocked and Mili answered. 
“Stan, Kenny What are you doing here?” She asks. You could tell she didn’t want to see us. 
“Is Y/n home? We need to talk to him,” I say.
“No, he’s not,” Mili says.
“Do you know where he is?” I ask.
“No,” she says and looks Kenny and I up and down.
“Alright thanks,” I nod and we head back to the car.
“Don’t you still have his number?” Kenny asks.
“Yeah I should, but do you think he’ll answer?” I ask. 
“Worth a shot,” Kenny shrugs. I nod and pull out my phone I dial Y/n’s number then put it on speaker. 
“Hello?” Y/n answers. I feel relief wash over me. 
“Hey dude, were are you? Kenny and I just stopped by your house and you weren’t home,” I say.
“I’m at Starks pond... I’ll meet you by the sign,” he says. 
“Yeah alright,” I say and hang up 
When we got to Starks Pond we saw Y/n by the sign he had a guitar and was holding onto his bike. Loki was resting on his shoulder. Kenny and I got out of the car and walked over to him. 
“Hey,” Y/n says as we get closer. 
*Normal Pov* 
You were up on the cliff when Stan called you. It was a place that you now went to often. You were really confused as to why Stan called you though. You still agreed to see him though. 
“Hey,” you greet Stan and Kenny. 
“We need to talk, what happened between you and Kyle?” Stan asks. 
“He didn’t tell you?” You ask as you cock your head to the side. 
“He did, but we want to get your side,” Stan says. 
“Well Cartman was beating the shit out of me almost every day to get me to break up with Kyle. I didn’t want to give Cartman that satisfaction, but then Kyle found out and broke up with me,” you explain. 
“I fucking knew there was a part being left out!” Stan exclaims. 
“Kyle wouldn’t be going out with Cartman if he knew that,” Kenny adds. 
“That’s relieving. Not that he’s going out with Cartman, but that he didn’t intentionally hurt me by getting with Cartman,” you sigh. 
“It won’t be long, were going to get you and Kyle back together and make sure Cartman doesn’t hurt you again or come back into the picture,” Stan says,” that is if you want to get back with Kyle.” You thought about it, you did want to get back together with Kyle. You loved him so much and you weren’t ready to let that go.
“Yeah alright, what were you thinking?” You ask. 
“Hold on let me grab the food!” Kenny says and runs to Stan’s car. He comes back with two bags and a drink carrier. You guys find a spot by the pond and Kenny hands you the milk shake. 
“Thanks,” you smile and take a sip. 
“So we need to “corner” Cartman. We need to get him to admit that it was him doing horrible shit to you,” Stan says. He uses a fat French fry to represent Cartman on his napkin. 
“Cartman’s easy to get mad,” Kenny says,” we could do something to get him to snap.”
“Yeah, how about at the talent show?” You ask. “I’ve gotten into music so I could do a “love song directed towards Kyle”. That would definitely piss him off.” You use two of Stan’s fries to represent you and Kyle.
“Yeah, we can then corner him in the bathroom and record a confession. We could show it to Kyle,” Stan says. Stan uses a fry to represent him and Kenny.
“And if things escalate we can step in,” Kenny nods. 
“We can have Token on mom duty too, if anyone gets hurt,” Kenny says.
“Yeah I think we should get Craig and them involved too, they were pissed when Cartman came back,” Stan says. Now pulling out more fries for the four boys.
“Butters is also going to be a judge so he can hint at it being about someone you love or had loved,” Kenny says as pulls out one last fry for Butters. 
“Alright let’s get everyone in on this,” Stan says and pulls out his phone. He puts on speaker for you and Kenny to hear.
“Fucker’s auto service you bring em, we fuck em,” Craig answers. You have to suppress a laugh. 
“Dude we have a plan to get Y/n back in our group and get Cartman the fuck out. You with the others?” Stan asks.
“Yeah we’re all hanging at my house,” Craig says.
“Alright we’ll be over in a few,” Stan says and hangs up. 
*Kyle’s Pov* 
I was with Cartman at his house. I’m still thinking about Y/n continuously. Was there a better way to have felt with it? Did I really have to break him by breaking up with him? But it hurt me seeing him get hurt by staying with me! He told me he was getting better with taking care of himself. But he did it because he loved me...and I loved him. Fuck I still love him! But we’re both in better situations...I’m happy with Cartman right...? 
“What’s my baby thinking about?” Cartman asks. 
“Oh nothing don’t worry about it,” I smile at him. 
“Alright...just tell me if something is wrong though,” he smiles and kisses me. 
*Normal Pov* 
“So any questions?” Stan asks as he finishes explaining the plan. 
“Uh yeah, why do I have to be on mom duty?” Token asks. 
“Well because out of all of us you give off the mom vibe the most, Tweek is a close second,” Stan says.
“I’ll do mom duty if Token doesn’t want to,” Tweek says. 
“Yeah alright,” Stan nods and types it out on his phone.
“Now Y/n do you know what song your going to do?” Craig asks. 
“Yeah, Happier by Ed Sheeran,” you say,” I already know most of the notes and it’s a love song.” 
“Yeah I think it’ll work,” Tweek nods. 
“You listen to Ed Sheehan Tweek?” Clyde asks.
“Y-yeah his m-music is really good,” Tweek stutters. 
You discussed the last few details then Stan brought you home. 
“I’m home mom!” You call to Mili.
“How was your time out?” She calls from the kitchen. You walk into the kitchen and sit at the breakfast bar. 
You explain to her your plan about exposing Cartman and getting Kyle back. 
“Well if it’s going to make you happy,” Mili sighs. You nod and smile. 
-Time Skip brought to you by Tweek Bros Coffee-
The talent show came faster then you thought it would. There were vendors and a small stage was set up on the football field. People could either sit in the stands or on the field. It was almost time.
“You ready dude?” Stan asks as you wait back stage.
“As ready as I’ll ever be,” you nod.