Matters of the Family (Pro-Hero Shoto Todoroki x Reader)

𝕌𝕟𝕗𝕒𝕚𝕣

Even after two weeks, Touya didn't stay over. You'd tried to get him to stay countless times but he refused, saying he didn't want to move too fast. You'd gotten to the time of year just after tourist season where you got no customers so it wasn't  good idea for you to keep the café open during this time which meant that you got about 2 months off work. Not that it meant that you could have a lie in because you had a five year old daughter. You were rudely awoken by thee feeling of her small body thudding down onto yours as she jumped on the bed, trying to get you to wake up. Begrudgingly, you sat up, trying to force yourself to wake up as she babbled in your ear about a dream she had last night. She barely gave you time to get dressed before she dragged you into the kitchen because she wanted pancakes. As you cooked them on the stove your phone began to buzz in your back pocket. Fishing it out, you answered before looking at the screen. A familiar voice that you'd not heard in a while flooded into your ears. Turning off the stove and giving Amai her food, you head into the hallway to speak to him. "Shoto? Was there something that you needed?" There was a pause on the other end of the phone. It was scaring you how quiet he was being. You stood and waited for his response. "I know it's been a while but....can I come over....I think we need to talk. All three of us." You were more than confused by his words but you thought it best to agree. "Uh...sure....are you free tonight? We can talk after Amai's gone to bed." He hums in agreement before hanging up. You were surprised by how blunt he was being. A million thoughts raced through your head as to what exactly he could want to talk to you about. You headed back into the living room, your brain spinning as you tried to keep Amai occupied until Touya arrived.

After an eventful day of Amai bouncing off the walls it was finally time for her to go to bed. You were both relieved and apprehensive. Amai going to sleep meant that Shoto would be coming over soon to talk.  After Touya helped you to tuck her in, you both headed into the living room where you proceeded to text Shoto to tell him that Amai had gone to bed and that he could come over. You rested your head on Touya's shoulder. "Do you have any idea what he wants to talk to us about? I'm actually kinda worried, he was being really off earlier." Touya seemed to think this over, his hand resting on your thigh. "Well, he did kinda just find out that the woman he loved rejected him only to start seeing his brother again...so....maybe that's why." You sat up abruptly and gaped at him. "Wait wait wait....he knows?" He shrugs before turning to look you in the eyes. "(Y/N), I almost lost my relationship with my brother when he found out I'd been keeping Amai a secret, I didn't wanna keep another one and risk ruining it again. Look, I did a lot of....awful things to him and his classmates when he was at UA because I thought he was the same as our dad....but....after I revealed my identity a few years ago he came looking for me. He didn't care that the other league members were there, he wanted to talk to me. And we kept in contact ever since, but Amai was the one thing I didn't tell him about. You can understand, right?" You let out a breath before nodding. "Yeah I guess I....wait....go back  sec...you said...the woman he loved?" Touya sighed and nodded also. "Yeah, makes me feel awful. He was head over heels. I'd never seen him so happy. It sucked to watch it but he understood that it wasn't what you wanted. I don't know why he's suddenly wanting to come here to talk though. When I told him I was trying to win you back he said he was fine with it and said it was probably best for Amai anyways." Touya shrugged and stood up to go into the kitchen to get a drink. You sat on the sofa, slightly stunned. You recalled that you'd accidentally let slip before that you loved him, right after you'd found out that him and Touya were brothers. Had he felt the same way then? 

The sound of the doorbell dragged you from your thoughts as you stood up to go and answer it. Opening the door revealed Shoto, looking very upset and dishevelled, the dark rings under his eyes startled you as you stepped aside to let him through. He headed straight into the living room ,leaving you to follow behind after you locked the door. He let out a strained breath as you sat down on the sofa, looking at at him tentatively. He looked almost out of place in your living room after so long. Touya sauntered back through with three bottles of water, handing one to each of you as he sat by you on the sofa. You both watched Shoto expectantly as he took a drink from his water. "Look, I originally came here to shout but...I know Amai's asleep. To be honest, I'm not even angry anymore. I've spent most of my life being denied things that I want because other things were more important, so when you rejected me it stung a little but it was something I was used to. But...the thing that hurt me most was finding out that, even thought you'd told me that your heart wasn't ready for love just yet, you started dating my brother again almost immediately after. So....what I really came to ask is...what's so wrong with me? Why am I not good enough?" His words hit your heart like a knife. You really had hurt him. You hadn't taken the time to think about the effect this could have had on him. This is why you'd never been a selfish person, even if it was for  your own benefit you had never put your own needs before someone else's. You looked down at your  hands in your lap trying to think of something to say. Your brain was working over time. You were snapped out of your thoughts when Amai came into the room, rubbing her eyes sleepily. "Mama, I had a bad dream, can you come chase the monsters away?" You looked over to her and instantly smiled, standing and going over to pick her up. "Of course I can princess." You turned to Shoto and Touya. "I'll be back once I've put her to bed." You turned and headed into Amai's room to put her back into bed. 

After making sure she was asleep, you carefully slipped out of her room and back into the living room where Shoto was now sat on the sofa with Touya. They both looked up as you came in, the looks in their eyes making you freeze slightly. They both stood and came over, Touya gently tucked some hair behind your ear while Shoto took your hand and brushed his lips gently against your knuckles, causing your eyes to widen. Touya was the first to speak. "We had a little chat while you were gone. We figured that, seeing as you'd slept with both of us, the best way for you to choose one of us would be to sleep with us both at the same time and decide who's best, hm?" You shuddered slightly as Touya's lips pressed into your neck, littering your skin with kisses as Shoto's hands skimmed up your exposed thighs and under your skirt. Your mind was barely functioning by this point. Finally, as their hands and mouths continued their assault on your skin, you broke. "Fine....let's do it."