Unexpected (James Phelps x Reader)

1.16

I believe that the song choice is self-explanatory 😏

"And I believe it's going to be quite a memory." He whispered devilishly into my ear and started kissing my neck. I bit my lower lip at his words.

Then his phone started ringing.

"Oh my got, just tell me why?!" James cried after I pulled away and climbed off him so he could get to the phone.

"Hello?" He talked into it. "I'll be right there." He said and rolled his eyes to which I left out a chuckle.

"It's the pizza." He stood up to go get it.

-----

After a few minutes, James came back to the living room with two pizza boxes, looking annoyed as never. I left out a giggle as our eyes met.

"What's so funny?" He asked raising his eyebrows. "You are." I answered. "Yeah?" He left our food on the table and came towards me. He leaned onto the couch with me sitting in between his hands. "Yeah, you're funny." I repeated.

James kissed my forehead. "Do you want to eat it now?" He asked. "Well... Later it's gonna be cold." I said. "Uhm sure." He pushed his body back up into a standing position. "Heyyy!" I grabbed his forearm. "Don't get cranky now." I smiled softly.

His eyes softened slightly but his eyebrows stayed furrowed. "What's the problem?" I asked. "There is none I'm just frustrated from how everything keeps getting in the way. And I know I said there would be no pressure and that we could only watch movies if that was how you'd feel... But knowing that we both want the same thing and instead are going to eat pizza doesn't exactly feel satisfying." He wrinkled his nose.

"Would you feel better if I only wanted to watch movies? Cuz I can do that." I snickered. "No! We're gonna eat the pizza and then I'm taking you to my bedroom. It's too late to turn around now." He said. And my eyes went wide open. "Wow, you really are eager." I laughed but this time it came out a little bit nervous.

He was having expectations. Looking forward to a certain experience. What if I couldn't fulfil it? I had no idea what he liked. And not much of an idea of what I could do either.

"Just cool down a little okay?" I said and it may have come out a little annoyed. He looked at me trying to figure out what it was about.

"Sorry. I didn't mean to pressure you like that." "Yeah well... I'm still nervous and in a way, I'm glad for the pizza coming." I looked down.

"No no no, I don't want you to be uncomfortable. Just forget what I said okay? We are gonna eat and we can watch some Netflix and just let it all go. Okay?" He handed me my pizza and I smiled. "Whatever happens, happens. If we just fall asleep or whatever it's still okay." James added.

"Thank you for understanding. It's not that I'd be uncomfortable around you. It's just a lot of stuff at once with me telling you and everything." I left the pizza on the couch and stood up to hug James.

This situation was weird. I knew he was a grown man and had needs and was expecting tonight to go a lot more smoothly than this. But his persistence still kind of threw me off. I knew I wanted to have that experience with James. Otherwise, I wouldn't tell him.

And I could feel my lower belly getting warmer just from the tight hug which was making the way I felt even more obvious.

"I don't wanna go to sleep." I mumbled into his chest. "Okay." He packed a kiss into my hair. "We'll play Monopoly then." He smirked looking down at me.