You Don't Want Me Like I Want You

Dreaming

    School came faster than Theo had thought it was going to. Not being able to bring himself to tell Liam the truth about why he woke up, Theo was now holding everything that he dreamed about a secret. Old dreams and new dreams.
    Last night he had dreamt about the girl again. Is her name Allison? the beta thought to himself as he read through his history book in the library. If the dreams were real, and that was younger Scott, then maybe that was a younger her.
    Not being able to control himself, Theo stood up before walking up the steps to the second level of the library. He read some of the yearbooks before he found the one from a few years back. Opening it up, he flipped through the pages before finding McCall, Scott in the sophomore section. The photo matched the dream perfectly.
    Flipping to the Freshman section, Theo slowly began to read through each other names. With them being in alphabetical order by last name, the male had to go through each one of them individually. It felt like it was going to take forever, especially if she was a senior that year with the last name Z.
    Getting to the sophomore section, Theo didn't have to go passed the first page of the class. He read the name many times, trying to register it completely before practically slamming the book shut. It couldn't be, could it?
    Getting to Scott's place again, Theo noticed the Jeep there meaning Scott was home. Should he tell Scott what he saw in his dream? Or should he wait? Looking at his phone, he had a text from Liam saying he was with Mason and Corey for the night so he wouldn't be texting much.
    Saying he was fine with it, Theo grabbed his bag and walked inside the house. So he could avoid an encounter, Theo rushed to his room and closed the door behind him. Telling Liam he was going to lie down, Theo took a shower before lying down in their bed. Closing his eyes, he drifted off slowly.

As the male opened his eyes, Theo was sitting in a house he didn't quite recognize. He couldn't make out what exactly it was, but he knew it was a two story house.
As the beta looked around, his eyes soon met with the girl from his dreams. Allison. She smiled brightly at him, her brown hair drifting over her shoulders as she watched Theo carefully.
"Where are we?" Theo asked her, knowing she wouldn't know the answer. It was a dream, wasn't it?
"At my house. Well, the house I lived in when I moved to Beacon Hills. I don't recognize you, though. How come you've been following me?"
Theo watched her confused for a moment before he thought of something to say. "I'm not following you. Not intentionally, at least. You've been in my dreams a lot recently."
"Do you know Scott McCall?"
"He's the reason I think I'm here. He bit me because I was going to die and I've been seeing you ever since then."
"He has a beta?"
"Multiple. Me, my boyfriend, and the my boyfriend's ex."
"You have a boyfriend? And Scott bit his ex?"
"I know. Big shocker to me as well. I never thought I'd date a guy. And she was going to die, so Scott did what he thought he had to in order to save her. She actually died once before."
"How'd she come back to life?"
"I was a bad guy."
Both of them chuckled lightly to each other before Allison's eyes widened. "You should tell the others about me."
"They wouldn't believe me. They'd think I'd gone insane or something."
"I know Scott. He wouldn't turn his back on anyone."
"He has before." The words came out of Theo's mouth and Allison's expression turned for eagerness to confusion. "Liam's ex, Hayden, had died before. Scott didn't bite her because he thought it would kill her. And he turned away from Liam for awhile. They all came together again, though, after my incident and all, and worked things out luckily."
"How long ago was this?"
"Start of Senior year. Not very long after what happened with you."
"You have to trust me, Theo. Scott will believe you. He has to. Tell him I said to say because I love you and he'll know it's real."