Peter The Pumpkin X Reader.

The decision.

You woke up to your alarm blaring, and quickly shut it off.
It had been almost a week since you had visited peter, and you wouldn't be lying if you said you missed him.
Every day since then Andy had been checking on you every morning to apologize and talk. You hadn't told him about peter, but you were planning too.
You got up and quickly threw on a oversized sweater and some tights.
You walked downstairs and conveniently the doorbell rung.
You opened it to a very worried looking Andy.
Andy: {"your Alright! Oh my god im so sorry for going along with that stupid prank, i-"}
You cut him off.
{"its fine Andy, but i just want to talk to you about what happened...lets go to the benches.."}
You grabbed his arm and walked him over to the benches where you both sat.
Andy: {"What happened in there? Did you get lost?"}
{"no Andy I didn't get lost, but there was....Someone in there."}
Andy stared at you.
Andy: {"y/n.....No one lives in that farm. The only thing is mice and cobwebs, maybe a few haystacks but thats it."}
The color drained from your face.
{"n-no, your kidding. There was a pumpkin guy in there,h-he was big and-"}
You were cut off by Andy grabbing your arm in a very tight hold.
Andy: {"maybe your right! Here, lets go and check."}
You felt frozen.
That wasn't Andy.
That.....

That was peter.
You don't know how,
But he was trying to get you closer, using Andy.

Your internal rambling was cut off by you and Andy entering the pitch black barn.
You felt him let go of your arm, you
immediately grabbed your arm and held where he had been holding.
It hurt like a bitch.
Andy: {"oh i see someone over there! Cmon!"}
He ran over to a doorway and disappeared as if he wasn't even there.
You frantically looked around for him, but you couldn't see a thing.
{"Andy?! W-where did you g-go?.."}
You felt tears start to sneak down your face.
Did he really just come here then leave you to die?
You slowly fell to the floor and buried your head in your knees as you weeped.
It had felt like hours when you finally heard footsteps, they where loud and sounded like they came from something...familiar
You looked up to see peter, towering over you.
Peter: {"you came back! I was thinking you weren't going to haha!~..are you Alright? Did you get lost? Terribly sorry about how dark it is, i should put some lanterns around."}
His voice was gentle, and sounded genuine.
He picked you up and put you back on your feet, you turned a bit red.
{"t-thanks...i was trying to tell my friend about our encounter but...he got weird and ran us over, he then left me here and I genuinely thought i was gonna die here haha.."}
He growled a bot hearing you say friend, but kept his kind smile.
Peter: {"that was horrible of them..why don't you follow me to   A comfier setting
where you can talk about it?"}
You nodded as he held your arm
Gently.
He guided you over to what seemed to be a small couch with a nice carpet under it.

(Yes he has a nice couch and carpet in the barn, take wattpad logic.)

He sat down on the couch as you did too.
Peter: {"you should stop talking to those people, y/n.
First they hide your keys and now they leave you here as some sick joke? Tsk Tsk.
You need to trust better people,
Why don't you stay in the barn with me? They cannot bother you in here~."}
You felt a sort of guilt,
But you realized something.

Something Andy said...

"No one lives in that barn"

You felt the same dread as when Klaus was dumb enough to ask Andy if he'd like to eat some apples.

{"s-sorry but i must deny the offer! I think I should go now, my friends might be worried with me not around haha!-}
You were shaking, you felt fear all up your spine.

Peter grabbed your arm and pulled you closer to him, he knelt to your size. He held up your chin and starred deep into your eyes

Peter: {"I'm not fond of that answer love, I'm going to give you a question and you can answer now or later.
Will you stay with me, or leave me to rot lonely forever?~"}
A ball of guilt held in your throat.
You didn't want to leave peter, you were starting to get attached to him.

You were starting to fall in love him.

Peter stood kneeling to your height, waiting for an answer from you.

You felt words creep up your throat, you couldn't control what you were about to say.

{"I'll st-"}
You were able to stop the words.

Peter's mouth turned into a frown.

Peter: {"i didn't catch that, what where you going to say?"}
You gulped.

{"I'm sorry...I don't...i."}

You couldn't decide.

You couldn't decide.

__________________
Another cliffhanger buddy.